Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
it is not about "songs". it is about STRUCTURE of some sort, any sort. even a couple or crescendos adds some sort of structure, however tenuous. otherwise it truly is sounds and not music. all sounds can be used to make music. but too many noise acts make just sounds. Ican deal with it but it is as tedious as an Interrpol show
|
yes but no.
i agree adding structure is one way to get there and it's something more people should explore that.
hmmm, actually i agree, when it comes down to it, it's because of structure, arrangements and orchestration that makes noise good or bad, even free improvisation isn't as wild or great if there's no direction going (even if dictated by inertia).
ps: never got why lightning bolt were considered noise, nor melt-banana...fuck, even wolf eyes, at least their earlier stuff, but the boring droning crap they have been doing of late, has a lot of musicality in them. they have fucking doom riffs and hardcore vocals going beneath the electronics.