|
That's weird kingcoffee because SY haven't been "known for noise" since Bad Moon Rising. EVOL was melodic, SISTER was melodic, Daydream Nation might be the only "unmelodic" album after Bad Moon Rising. Goo was melodic, Dirty was melodic, EJST&NS wasn't really very melodic, Washing Machine was melodic, A Thousand Leaves wasn't, NYG&F wasn't melodic, Murray Street "tried" to be melodic, Nurse was melodic.
As far as I remember, SY have been about melody and that's exactly what they did with Rather Ripped. I don't quite see the Nurse or Murray ST comparison. Have you heard their album GOO or DIRTY? You'll hear alot of GOO(especially from TUNIC & CINDERELLA'S BIG SCORE), but I don't hear anything that reminds me of Nurse or Murray Street.
You don't have to be sorry either. It's your opinion, dude.
|