Quote:
|
Originally Posted by GeneticKiss
With threads like this, I can't help but wonder exactly what those who've said they were disappointed with The Eternal were expecting. Sonic Nurse Part II? A main SY release that sounds like an SYR? One long track? Maybe SY pretending to be Hair Police?
To me, any of those would be disappointing at best and completely ill-conceived at worst.
|
No, but something more inventive. i dont mean similar. All the other albums where different and somehow inventive, this one is a step back. Its true, they didnt do this before, but others did, like queens of the stonage or green day, and i just dont like that kinda music. I expected something more innovative, more experimental, more in the direction of the destroyed room, than just riding the classical rock riffs again. There are good ideas on malibu, poisen arrow, walkin blues, and maybe others, but these songs are on the one hand just not finished to be pop songs, and on the other hand not interesting enough for standalone soundparts - in my ears. And i do understand that massage the history is a good song, but it doesnt get me. So, lets say, its just my personal taste. Some people here dont like ejtans or dirty, which i consider to be nothing less than brilliant, so let me dislke the eternal, please :-)
oh, and yes, one long track would be interesting.
And its not just because they become more poppy. It hasnt to be neccessarily noisy, though i like noise - but - it should be interesting. This one for ex. is terrible poppy, but interesting:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ghP3DD2t6s