Nah the top one is the one I'm currently looking at. I just really love that design so much.
I have the one of these
I like it a lot. close buttons...the stick is a bit short...my only issue with it is that it's incredibly light and I constantly have to adjust it since it slides around quite a bit. Though...with the next gen consoles comin' out...I guess I'll just wait a bit.
Oh yeah! I have a PS360+ PCB in my stick(dualmodded for xbox) and you can actually update the PCB. They announced that they will have a firmware update to allow compatibility with the PS4....but not the XBONE(not that I care....for now).