Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
goo above daydream nation?? and i thought MY SY opinions were controversial!
here is my non SYR ranking
1. sonic nurse
2. a thousand leaves
3. daydream nation
4. sister
5. the eternal
6. dirty
7. washing machine
8. rather ripped
9. EVOL
10. nyc ghosts and flowers
11. sonic death
12. made in usa
13. bad moon rising
14. murray street
15. goo
16. confusion is sex
17. experimental jet set trash no star (and everytime i listen to this record i feel like i am dissing it putting it unanimously at the bottom of the list, i mean there are some really good songs on it BUT everytime i make this list it always finds its way here at the bottom)
|
My opinion has always been GOO is better than DDN. Goo was my first SY-album, listened quite soon also DDN and thought then it had nothing to add to GOO although of course it was great too. In GOO I think only Kool Thing is a little bit boring song. Both albums have one song in my top10, Candle & Disappearer.
No hardness to understand why you prefer Nurse so much, but when you like Nurse so much, why Murray is so low? I think those two have lots in common, the reason why Murray is above Nurse in my list is I just love so much Karen revisited and there are not such a trip in Nurse (well Nurse has I love You Golden Blue thatīs in my top10 sonic songs).
I feel also bad to put Experimental in the end of the list, because itīs just so much greater than many other albums, but in my sonicology itīs just the lowest.