[Severian]

Originally Posted by Diesel

And yet Kanye is alright to align with Trump though?
I'm not sure why you'd compare the Stone Roses to Oasis as they have nothing in common other than geography. Same with the Beatles. I'm pretty sure both of these bands never played loud, distorted power chords and had a town crier for a singer - a band like The La's have far more indebted influence. You've repeated the cliche bullshit as was written by journalists who took anything auld big heads would say as gospel for a headline grab. Bigger than the Beatles et al. Guest merely pointed it out.

No, I was saying even BLUR’s early, “weeny Stone Roses” stuff is better than Oasis if you have to compare the two.

Also, no, until Kanye walks back his Trump support, there’s no defense for the way the moron acts in public. I can’t just make myself unlike his music, but as a person he’s full of shit and I think I’ve been pretty clear about my feelings on TrumpYe.

I legitimately don’t know or care if you think I’m repeating what music journalists write. Most music journalists make me want to puke and I read very little of it anymore and certainly don’t base my opinions on what they have to say, but think what you want.

Dont early Oasis lyrics have you believe they are under-class outcasts?

Yes, that’s part of my fucking point. Or the point of my pointless shittalking. Yes. Jesus Christ. Read!

I know a couple of lads who are in well paid management roles who are mod Oasis freaks. They volunteered to clean Shields beach and ended up sacking it off to go on the lash all day. Just a couple of good time George sand dancer lads wanting a knees-up. Canny as owt; wouldn't touch yr mother! Now, if they were Blur fans it's guaranteed that once the beach was clean they would be home in time for the one show, then settling down for recipes from the bass players cook book before congregating for midnight mass. Which would you rather be?

Yeah, again, I didn’t really mean it. I figured I could get away with being a crass asshole about Oasis, but apparently being an asshole is reserved for others.

The music you like doesn’t impact or change your class or intelligence, or vice versa. Your class doesn’t determine your intelligence, or vice versa. (I’m sure there are correlations, but those are meaningless without context).

Jesus I don’t even hate Oasis that much. Some hummable songs. Mostly garbage, but whatever.

I’m not passionate enough about Oasis one way or the other to even keep taking about this, but I want to make it clear that Guest is an asshole who only pops in to say nasty shit and judge people, mercifully only about twice a year.

Also wanna reiterate that the comparison was between Blur and Stone Roses, not Oasis. Though Oasis probably has more in common with Stone Roses than they did with the Beatles. Sound fucking nothing like the Beatles, honestly. Few chord choices here and there are Beatle-rips, but there’s very little similarity sonically.