Quote:
|
Originally Posted by marleypumpkin
For fucks sake you straight up attack me for posting something you don't like, which in no way takes anything away from you that you might feel for any given topic. & you say that I make this forum terrible to be on.
There's plenty of people on this forum who appreciate both of their main style of songwriting. Which in turn made me think it would be interesting to talk about music.
|
Hey man, don't worry. I don't think it was personal. When you open up a discussion like this (which should maybe be in Non-Sonic Sounds), you should expect some people to respond with negative remarks, because it's an opinion-based thing and you're asking what people like and saying, "This is what I like."
So to a certain extent, the "They both suck" stuff should be expected. But again I don't think it was personal.
NOW, as for me... I don't actually fucking know.
My gut just wants to say Lou Reed, but that's because he's just this huge personality for me, and one of my favorite artists ever, and fronted one of my favorite bands ever.
But is he my favorite songwriter? Hmm. Probably not actually.
And is he my favorite guitarist? No. Certainly not. That would be a really weird choice.
So I'll have to think about it and get back to you.
Favorite guitarist and favorite songwriter are gonna be two different people though, certainly. I don't see these things as being one and the same. Lots of good songwriters don't play guitar, or suck at it.
Hmmmm