I think people are unduly critical of Billy Corgan. The reason he played most of the parts of Siamise dream is because the rest of the band just weren't interested. I think his "whine" is something you either love or hate, much like Kim Gordon's voice (Ive heard people tell, me they would like sonic youth, but Kim's voice is to grating). For me his voice on all of the albums really makes the music work.
|