Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   give every sonic album rate (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=24246)

mil_pl 08.11.2008 06:46 AM

give every sonic album rate
 
from 1 to 10.

sonic youth 4/10
confusion is sex 3/10
bad moon rising 5/10
evol 9/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 9/10
goo 5/10
dirty 9/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 6/10
washing machine 4,5/10
a thousand leaves 9,5/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 9/10
murray street 9,5/10
sonic nurse 10/10 (my fave album)
rather ripped 7/10
the eternal 6/10

the whitey album 4/10
made in usa 7/10
demonlover 8/10
the destroyed room 6/10

syr1 9/10 (my fave syr)
2 6/10
3 4/10
4 7/10
5 5/10
6 5/10
7 6/10
8 8/10
9 8/10

tv shit 1/10
silver session 2/10
kali yug express 8,5/10
in the fishtank 6/10
hidros3 3,5/10

thurston:
psychic hearts 7/10
trees outside the academy 8,5/10
demolished thoughts 9/10

atsonicpark 08.11.2008 06:51 AM

I'll only allow one 10.

sonic youth 8/10
confusion is sex 10/10
bad moon rising 8/10
evol 7/10
sister 8/10
daydream nation 9/10
goo 6/10
dirty 5/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 4/10
washing machine 7/10
a thousand leaves 9/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 8/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 5/10
rather ripped 3/10
the whitey album 4/10

syr1 8/10
2 7/10
3 5/10
4 9/10
5 7/10
6 6/10
7 6/10
8 7/10
silver sessions: 9/10
tv shit: heh.. I like it, but probably 3/10

Uh..

ZEROpumpkins 08.11.2008 06:51 AM

sonic youth 7/10
confusion is sex 7/10
bad moon rising 9/10
evol 8/10
sister 9.5/10
daydream nation 10/10
goo 7.5/10
dirty 6.5/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 7/10
washing machine 8.5/10
a thousand leaves 6/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 7/10
murray street 8/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 7/10

atsonicpark 08.11.2008 06:52 AM

I didn't do point 5's or anything.

ZEROpumpkins 08.11.2008 06:52 AM

Note that Sister is my favourite but DDN has more reason to get a 10/10.

Derek 08.11.2008 06:55 AM

sonic youth 7/10
confusion is sex 7/10
bad moon rising 8/10
evol 10/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 10/10
goo 7/10
dirty 3/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 2/10
washing machine 8/10
a thousand leaves 6/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 8/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 7/10
rather ripped 6/10
the whitey album 5/10

syr1 7/10
2 6/10
3 6/10
4 7/10
5 4/10
6 6/10
7 7/10
8 7/10
silver sessions: 6/10
tv shit: 4/10

andrei 08.11.2008 07:48 AM

sonic youth - 7
confusion is sex - 7
bad moon rising - 9
evol - 8
sister - 8
daydream nation - 8
goo - 3
dirty - 7
experimental jet set, trash and no star - 6
washing machine - 7
a thousand leaves - 8
nyc ghosts & flowers - 10
murray street - 7
sonic nurse - 10
rather ripped - 2
the whitey album - --- (i can't figure out how to rate this)

SYR1 - 6
SYR2 - 7
SYR3 - 8
SYR4 - --- (same as with Whitey Album)
SYR5 - 8
SYR6 - 5
SYR7 - 6
SYR8 - 9

silver sessions - 10
tv shit - --- (same as SYR4 and Whitey)
Hidros - 10
In The Fishtank - 8
Demonlover - 9
Kali Yug Express - 9

mil_pl 08.11.2008 08:01 AM

experimental jet set, trash and no star 2/10

that is radical step Derek!

atsonicpark 08.11.2008 08:02 AM

I'm seeing a constant trend.. low ratings to EXPERIMENTAL and RIPPED.

Who'd've thought!

al shabbray 08.11.2008 08:37 AM

sonic youth 7/10
confusion is sex 8/10
bad moon rising 7/10
evol 8/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 10/10
goo 6/10
dirty 6/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 7/10
washing machine 8/10
a thousand leaves 9/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 9/10
murray street 10/10
sonic nurse 7/10
rather ripped 6/10
the whitey album 7/10

_slavo_ 08.11.2008 08:42 AM

sonic youth 5/10
confusion is sex 6/10
bad moon rising 8/10
evol 9,5/10 (0,5 down for "Bubblegum")
sister 7/10
daydream nation 8/10
goo 7/10
dirty 6/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 3/10
washing machine 9/10
a thousand leaves 7,5/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 8/10
murray street 8/10
sonic nurse 6/10
rather ripped 4/10
the whitey album 6/10

I ain't rating SYRs ... I'm not in the mood for that now.

HECKLER SPRAY 08.11.2008 08:49 AM

Sonic Youth - 06/10
Confusion is Sex - 07/10
Bad Moon Rising - 07/10
EVOL - 08/10
Sister - 10/10 !!!!
Daydream Nation - 09/10
Goo - 08/10
Dirty - 06/10
EJSTANS - 05/10
Washing Machine - 07/10
A thousand Leaves - 08/10
NYC Ghosts and Flowers - 08/10
Murray Street - 05/10
Sonic Nurse - 06/10
Rather Ripped - ....2.5/10

Cantankerous 08.11.2008 08:51 AM

sonic youth 6/10
confusion is sex 9/10
bad moon rising 8/10
evol 8/10
sister 10/10
daydream nation 10/10
goo 7/10
dirty 6/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 1/10
washing machine 1/10
a thousand leaves 7/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 1/10
murray street 6/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 0/10
the whitey album 6/10

gualbert 08.11.2008 09:03 AM

EJSTNS is a very good album , and a good SY album.

terriblecanyons 08.11.2008 09:26 AM

Why does everyone hate Rather Ripped? I think it's okay...

sonic youth 4/10
confusion is sex 4/10
bad moon rising 5/10
evol 7/10
sister 8/10
daydream nation 9/10
goo 7/10
dirty 8/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 7/10
washing machine 7/10
a thousand leaves 8/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 9/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 7/10

samuel 08.11.2008 09:28 AM

sonic youth 8/10
confusion is sex/kill yr idols 8/10
bad moon rising 8/10
evol 9/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 7/10
goo 7/10
dirty 7/10
experimental jet set 8/10
washing machine 9/10
a thousand leaves 10/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 9/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 6/10

--

the whitey album 8/10
syr1 9/10
syr2 8/10
syr3 9/10
syr4 7/10
syr5 6/10
syr6 6/10
syr7 8/10
syr8 9/10

noisereductions 08.11.2008 10:11 AM

from 1 to 10.

sonic youth 8/10
confusion is sex 9/10
bad moon rising 7/10
evol 10/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 9/10
goo 8/10
dirty 9/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 7/10
washing machine 7/10
a thousand leaves 8/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 8/10
murray street 9/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 8/10

the whitey album 9/10

syr1 8/10
2 8/10
3 6/10
4 6/10
5 5/10
6 6/10
7 8/10
8 7/10
tv shit 1/10
hidros3 6/10
In the fishtank 4/10
Demonlover 6/10
Made In USA 8/10

Pookie 08.11.2008 10:48 AM

sonic youth 4/10
confusion is sex 8/10
bad moon rising 10/10
evol 9/10
sister 9/10
daydream nation 6/10
goo 8/10
dirty 8/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 7/10
washing machine 6/10
a thousand leaves 8/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 8/10
murray street 6/10
sonic nurse 6/10
rather ripped 7/10

the whitey album 2/10

ruben 08.11.2008 11:12 AM

sonic youth 5/10
confusion is sex 8/10
bad moon rising 9/10
evol 9/10
sister 10/10
daydream nation 9/10
goo 7/10
dirty 4/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 6/10
washing machine 6/10
a thousand leaves 7/10
murray street 8.5/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 7/10

the whitey album 3/10

syr 3 7/10
syr 4 6/10
syr 6 6/10
syr 7 8/10
syr 8 9/10
Made In USA 9/10

SuperCreep 08.11.2008 11:23 AM

Sonic Youth: 8/10
Confusion Is Sex: 9/10
Bad Moon Rising: 9/10
EVOL: 9.5/10
Sister: 10/10
Daydream Nation: 10/10
Goo: 9/10
Dirty: 9/10
Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star: 9/10
Washing Machine: 10/10
A Thousand Leaves: 9.5/10
NYC Ghosts & Flowers: 8/10
Murray Street: 9/10
Sonic Nurse: 9/10
Rather Ripped: 8.5/10

SYR1: 8/10
SYR2: 7/10
SYR3: 7.5/10
SYR4: 8/10
SYR5: 4/10
SYR6: 5/10
SYR7: 5/10
SYR8: 8/10
The Whitey Album: 8/10
TV Shit: 1/10
Silver Sessions: 7.5/10

I'm probably going to get crucified for giving out such high rates, but whatevz. I really love this band.

matt g 08.11.2008 11:56 AM

sonic youth - 8/10
confusion is sex/kill yr idols - 6/10
bad moon rising - 6/10
evol - 9/10
sister - 10/10
daydream nation - 10/10
goo - 7/10
dirty - 7/10
ejst&ns - 6/10
washing machine - 5/10
a thousand leaves - 8/10
nycg&f - 7/10
murray street - 9/10
sonic nurse - 8/10
rather ripped - 7/10

syr1 - 7/10
syr2 - 6/10
syr3 - 6/10
syr4 - 5/10
syr5 - 8/10
syr6 - 5/10
syr7 - 6/10
syr8 - 7/10

tv shit - 4/10
made in usa - 6/10
whitey album - 8/10
suburbia - 8/10
silver sessions - 6/10
hidros 3 - 5/10
in the fishtank - 5/10
the destroyed room - 7/10

xxlouiisxx 08.11.2008 12:33 PM

sonic youth - 9/10
confusion is sex/kill yr idols - 10/10
bad moon rising - 9/10
evol - 9,5/10
sister - 9,5/10
daydream nation - 10/10
goo - 9/10
dirty - 9/10
ejst&ns - 9/10
washing machine - 9/10
a thousand leaves - 9/10
nycg&f - 9/10
murray street - 9/10
sonic nurse - 9/10
rather ripped - 9/10

I'm being kind but I've just never heard a band better than SY

Rob Instigator 08.11.2008 12:36 PM

my ratings

sonic youth 8/10 (I do not like Satan Is Boring)
confusion is sex 9/10
bad moon rising 9/10
evol 10/10
sister 10/10
daydream nation 100/10
goo 9/10
dirty 9/10
experimental jet set, trash and no star 1/10
washing machine 8/10
a thousand leaves 9/10
nyc ghosts & flowers 7/10
murray street 7/10
sonic nurse 9/10
rather ripped 8/10

the whitey album 8/10


sonic youth is my all time fave band!!!!!

Derek 08.11.2008 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mil_pl
experimental jet set, trash and no star 2/10

that is radical step Derek!

I hate that album.

Rob Instigator 08.11.2008 12:56 PM

me tooooo

mil_pl 08.11.2008 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
rather ripped 0/10


why is that ? you hate all songs ? :eek:

SonicBebs 08.11.2008 02:43 PM

Sister 8/10
Daydream Nation 4/10
Goo 4/10
Dirty 7/10
EJSTANS 4/10
Washing Machine 9/10
A Thousand Leaves 9/10
NYC Ghosts and FLowers 9/10
Murray Street 10/10
Nurse 9/10
Rather Rippd 7/10

SYR1 7
SYR2 7
SYR3 8
SYR5 3
SYR6 8
SYR8 7

dont have the others

jetengine 08.11.2008 03:29 PM

Sonic Youth 6.5/10
Confusion Is Sex 9/10
Kill Yr. Idols 6.5/10
Sonic Death 6.5/10
Bad Moon Rising 7/10
Death Valley '69 7/10
Walls Have Ears 7.5/10
EVOL 7/10
Sister 9/10
Master=Dik 5.5/10
Daydream Nation 10/10
Candle 6/10
Ciccone Youth: The Whitey Album 7.5/10
4 Tunna Brix 6/10
Goo 7.5/10
Dirty Boots Live 7/10
The Goo Demos 6.5/10
Venlo/Live '83 5.5/10
Dirty 7.5/10
Whore's Moaning 7/10
T.V. Shit 5/10
Experimental Jet Set, Trash, and No Star 6/10
Blastic Scene 6.5/10
Live in Bremen 6.5/10
Washing Machine 9/10
SYR1 6.5/10
SYR2 7/10
SKR1: The Silver Sessions 7.5/10
A Thousand Leaves 9.5/10
SYR3 7.5/10
SYR4 8/10
NYC Ghosts & Flowers 7/10
Murray St. 7/10
In The Fishtank 6/10
Hidros 3 7/10
Sonic Nurse 8/10
SYR5 7/10
Rather Ripped 8/10
The Destroyed Room 7/10
SYR6 (Haven't heard it yet)
SYR7 (Haven't heard it yet)

The Reissues:

Dirty Deluxe 8.5/10
Goo Deluxe 7/10 (Three LPs spread out over 8 sides with many of the b-sides and live tracks left off--I think many of us were unsatisfied with this repackaging.)
Sonic Youth Deluxe 7.5/10
Daydream Nation Deluxe 8/10 (Again, they should have included all the b-sides and more demos, instead of live tracks which have been bootlegged a dozen times over.)


Did I forget anything?

mil_pl 08.11.2008 03:39 PM

bootleg is not an album. we are rating only official realeses. but it's ok, you've done your homework with surplus! ;)

Derek 08.11.2008 03:42 PM

those bootlegs are official bootlegs though

al shabbray 08.11.2008 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SonicBebs
Sister 8/10
Daydream Nation 4/10
Goo 4/10
Dirty 7/10
EJSTANS 4/10
Washing Machine 9/10
A Thousand Leaves 9/10
NYC Ghosts and FLowers 9/10
Murray Street 10/10
Nurse 9/10
Rather Rippd 7/10

SYR1 7
SYR2 7
SYR3 8
SYR5 3
SYR6 8
SYR8 7

dont have the others


cheers another murray lover...but the DDN diss....BUT you love murray street

SonicBebs 08.11.2008 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jetengine
Did I forget anything?


can't believe you left off Hold That Tiger. Call yourself a Fan...?

SonicBebs 08.11.2008 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by al shabbray
cheers another murray lover...but the DDN diss....BUT you love murray street


ha! Never liked DDN. too clumpchy sounding.

but yeah, Murray Street! Woo!

SonicBebs 08.11.2008 04:06 PM

that didn't mean to sound as sarcastic as that

SYRFox 08.11.2008 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
my ratings

sonic youth 8/10 (I do not like Satan Is Boring)

wait... what?

SYRFox 08.11.2008 04:16 PM

I'd go like this

Sonic Youth -> 8/10
Confusion Is Sex -> 10/10
Bad Moon Rising -> 15000/10
Evol -> 9/10
Sister -> 9/10
Daydream Nation -> 9/10
Goo -> 6.5/10
Dirty -> 7/10
Experimental Jet Set, Trash And No Star -> 8/10
Washing Machine -> 8/10
A Thousand Leaves -> 8/10
NYC Ghosts & Flowers -> 10/10
Murray Street -> 7/10
Sonic Nurse -> 9/10
Rather Ripped -> 7/10

Sonic Death -> 9/10
Made In USA -> 7/10
The Whitey Album -> 8.274/10.000 (it's weird so I give it a weird rating)
The Destroyed Room -> 7.5/10

SYR1: 8/10
SYR2: 7.5/10
SYR3: 9.5/10
SYR4: 8.5/10
SYR5: 8/10
SYR6: 9/10
SYR7: 7.5/10
SYR8: not listened yet

TV Shit: EEIGGGGGGHHHHHHHT OUT OF TEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN
Silver Sessions: 9/10

That's right. I gave everything a good rate. So what? I can't be objective with them, I love everything they've done and that's it :D

acousticrock87 08.11.2008 04:29 PM

Sonic Youth - 6/10
Confusion is Sex(/Kill Yr Idols) - 8/10
Bad Moon Rising - 7/10
Evol - 6/10
Sister - 7/10
Daydream Nation - 9/10
Goo - 5/10
Dirty - 9/10
Experimental Jet Set - 10/10 (yep)
Washing Machine - 5/10
A Thousand Leaves - 9/10
NYC - 10/10
Murray Street - 9/10
Sonic Nurse - 5/10 (though I've probably listened to it less than any others, so I'm not sure)
Rather Ripped - 6/10

Others (I don't own very many):

Sonic Death - 8/10
Whitey Album - 6/10
SYR 6 - 6/10
Lundeberg EP - 9/10
Destroyed Room - 10/10
DDN Deluxe - 9/10
Psychic Hearts - 7/10
Trees Outside the Academy - 5/10

The three tens (EJS, NYC, and Destroyed Room) are hands-down my favorite, with ATL, Dirty, and Murray very close.

Rob Instigator 08.11.2008 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
wait... what?


satan is boring bores me.

SYRFox 08.11.2008 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
satan is boring bores me.

yeah sure... but it's on bad moon rising

SuperCreep 08.11.2008 04:48 PM

Errr...isn't Satan Is Boring on the reissue of BMR?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:06 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth