Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   MY Top 50 ROCK GODS (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=1988)

Rob Instigator 05.18.2006 04:26 PM

MY Top 50 ROCK GODS
 
These are not gonna be in any specific order. That is too hard to do

Jimi Hendrix
Chuck Berry
John Lennon
Keith Richards
Ozzy Osborne
Tony Iommi
Lemmy Kilmister
Iggy Pop
John Fogerty
Jim Morrison
Ray Manzarek
Thurston Moore
Lee Ranaldo
Neil Young
J Mascis
Michael Stipe
Gibby Haynes
David Byrne
Joey Ramone
Dee Dee Ramone
Joe Strummer
Glenn Danzig
JImmy Page
Eddie Van Halen
David Lee Roth
Gene Simmons
Paul Stanley
Peter Criss
Ace Frehley
Neil Peart
Ian McKaye
Morrissey
Robert Smith
Steve Albini


etc etc etc etc etc

nomadicfollower 05.18.2006 04:51 PM

Minus Keith Richards, you got it.

LifeDistortion 05.18.2006 04:55 PM

You have all of KISS up there, surely Mike Patton could replace one of them to make that list.

collarbone 05.18.2006 05:20 PM

Not ONE woman is mentioned. Sad..

Glice 05.18.2006 05:27 PM

50 women would be difficult, no? I can think of:

Kim G
Kim D
Courtney L (controversial, but she merits her place)
Joan Jett
Patti Smith
Bjork
Madonna (pushing it a bit)
Siouxie Sioux
Ari Up
Kathleen Henna
Nico
Dolly Parton (pushing it a bit, but she belongs in every list of good things)
Skin from Skunk Anansie (who doesn't belong apart from being a woman)
Justine Frischmann
Sainkho Namchylek (Doesn't belong, but I love her)
Diamonda Galas (stretching it)
Brix Smith
Chicks on Speed (I don't know any of their singular names)
Peaches

... and I'm out of ideas.

I hereby challenge other people to complete a list of 50 women.

dietzer123 05.18.2006 05:29 PM

i could do without morrisey, roth, van halen, and kiss. other than that very nice

TheMadcapLaughs 05.18.2006 05:33 PM

Don't forget the gals from Sleater-Kinney, Satomi from Deerhoof, Janis Joplin, Kristin Hersh, Grace Slick, and uhhhh the donnas? just kidding they are beyond rock godesses, hahaha

TheMadcapLaughs 05.18.2006 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dietzer123
i could do without morrisey, roth, van halen, and kiss. other than that very nice


agreed, but im sure he grew up with these bands, so thats why he has the "MY" in there

soapbars 05.18.2006 05:50 PM

val halen what?

heres the factual list,

1: mark e smith,

2 - onwards: everyone else is music in no particular order

3. popular music artists including elton john, will young, westlife, wham,

3: artists in shite bands including, oasis, green day, hard fi, the kooks, twisted sister, metalica, fall out boy, panic at the disco, him, slipknot, blink 182, pearl jam, embrace etc,

4: people involved in the endless growing amount of post-libs indie bands with members aged 15 to 25 that all love pete doherty,

EDIT i have difficulty counting whisting making simple short lists

HaydenAsche 05.18.2006 06:13 PM

You listed a lot of mediocre artists.

Hip Priest 05.18.2006 06:22 PM

More women

Julia Neagle (The Fall)
Danielle Dax
Lydia Lunch
Someone from Veruca Salt? (don't know names, but their first LP was ace - heard nothing since!)
The woman in the Subways (very cool, don't know her name)
Laila from The Duke Spirit (very very cool)
Leslie Keffer
Jemima (?) from Be Your Own Pet

youthoftomorrow 05.18.2006 07:08 PM

nice list, Rob

i see Jimmy Page, but i don't see Robert Plant.

i see Glenn Danzig and Ian MacKaye, but i don't see Henry Rollins.

HaydenAsche 05.18.2006 07:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by youthoftomorrow
but i don't see Henry Rollins.


Gods can't wear spandex.

trance feeeedback 05.18.2006 07:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HaydenAsche
You listed a lot of mediocre artists.

Indeed.

Plus you forgot Yoshimi of the boredoms and Bilinda Butcher of My Bloody Valentine in the female list.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 05.18.2006 07:20 PM

I like my list better:
Elvis
Buddy Holly
Chuck Berry
Richie Valens
John Lennon
Lou Reed
David Bowie
Brian Jones
Syd Barrett
Jimi Hendrix
Jimmy Page
Iggy Pop
John Bonham
Keith Moon
Pete Townshend
Robert Pollard
Kurt Cobain
Darby Crash
Sid Vicious
Kim Gordon
Frank Black
PJ Harvey
Richard Hell
Marc Bolan
Ian Curtis
Ozzy Osbourne
Gene Simmons
Rob Halford
Freddie Mercury
Jim Morrison
Johnny Rotten
Joe Strummer
Joey Ramone
Glenn Danzig
Mark Mothersbaugh
Guy Picciotto
Henry Rollins
Andy Gill
Anthony Keetis
Jim Reid
John Entwistle
Roger Daltry
Eddie Van Halen
David Lee Roth
John Paul Jones
Robert Plant
Kevin Shields
Jonathan Richman
Daniel Ash

Toilet & Bowels 05.18.2006 07:26 PM

it's all well and good being PC and listing 50 women, but how many of those women belong on a list of all time rock greats? respect to kathleen hannah and everything, but she's hardly a patch on lemmy.

HaydenAsche 05.18.2006 07:27 PM

Kathleen is just a patch of hair on some feminist's leg.

dietzer123 05.18.2006 07:42 PM

janis joplin should probably be in the top 50 and DEFFINETLY be in the top female rock stars

dietzer123 05.18.2006 07:46 PM

and gracie slick for females

A Thousand Threads 05.19.2006 01:49 AM

iŽd add Mark E. Smith to your list


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:37 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth