Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Artists who's genre is often mislabeled by people (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=19282)

ZEROpumpkins 01.28.2008 03:24 AM

Artists who's genre is often mislabeled by people
 
Include the band's actual genre and what they are mislabeled as.
eg. Melvins are Sludge/Stoner/Doom Metal but are often labeled as Grunge by those who have heard Houdini (which I still think isn't very grungy).

ALIEN ANAL 01.28.2008 03:31 AM

i can see where this thread will go

good luck

ZEROpumpkins 01.28.2008 03:36 AM

In that case:
I would hardly classify Battles as Math Rock. I'm not saying it's unrelated, but they're far more experimental than math.
And Slint should be referred to as Math Rock more commonly than Post Rock.

Norma J 01.28.2008 03:41 AM

Genres don't mean a thing to me. That's why I always tend to use quotation marks when using one. Most bands are mis-genre-casted. Which is a reason I don't think they hold much weight at all, not to mention people put far too much emphasis on them, like they have to classify the band/music rather than listening to the damn thing.

We're all victims of it from time to time. Some more than others.

sonicl 01.28.2008 04:16 AM

The only way to find out if a band's genre is mislabelled is to ask them what genre they intended to be. And 99% of bands questioned will say that they don't see themselves as being part of a genre. The other 1% will be made up of teenagers who will categorise themselves as either stoner/doom and teenagers who will categorise themselves as noise.

ZEROpumpkins 01.28.2008 05:33 AM

I still think that genre is important, as it gets you into a lot of new music.

Norma J 01.28.2008 05:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
The only way to find out if a band's genre is mislabelled is to ask them what genre they intended to be. And 99% of bands questioned will say that they don't see themselves as being part of a genre. The other 1% will be made up of teenagers who will categorise themselves as either stoner/doom and teenagers who will categorise themselves as noise.


I always found that most bands put their sound under what they want to be, whether they sound like that or not.

ZEROpumpkins 01.28.2008 06:18 AM

Actually genre doesn't bother me that much, unless people mislabel bands, that just pisses me off.

batreleaser 01.28.2008 09:19 AM

generally if youre in a band tho, or as at least for me anyways, i usually take a few influences and try to at least shoot for a certain sound.

EyeballGrowth 01.28.2008 07:20 PM

How about some artists who's genre's are often mislabled with genre's that people just pull out of their ass. Like Math rock, or sludge metal, or etc etc etc

Cantankerous 01.28.2008 08:26 PM

pink floyd is often mislabeled as progressive rock, which is not really a genre at all, it's a media-friendly term that doesn't mean anything. i don't know what the fuck they're supposed to mean by progressive...they got the "rock" bit right though.

Savage Clone 01.28.2008 08:28 PM

Anybody with an acoustic instrument/"folk"

Toilet & Bowels 01.28.2008 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Savage Clone
Anybody with an acoustic instrument/"folk"


how's your solo acoustic folk thing going?

Cantankerous 01.28.2008 08:34 PM

all this genre business has really gotten a bit out of control. i don't know where people come up with terms like "post-rock" and "math-rock" and whatnot. i don't know what some of this shit is.

glam rock, space rock, psychedelic rock -- ok, yeah, that all makes sense. even shoegaze makes sense if you know why it's called that (although it does little to nothing to foreshadow the sound of the music, then again either does any other genre if you think about it)

i don't understand the ins and outs of the music business so therefore unless you have in your hand a reasonable record contract for me and aren't going to make up a brand new genre every time a new band comes out, KISS MY ASS.

Savage Clone 01.28.2008 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
how's your solo acoustic folk thing going?



I've been concentrating on band stuff lately, but I should be getting more into that again in spring or summer I imagine. I still theoretically have a track slated for an upcoming compilation, but I haven't heard any projected release info from the label so I'm not sure when that's happening exactly.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth