whats the worst album?
 

the eternal

TV Shit

and for full length?

hmm.

dirty probably. If not, then Rather Ripped, obviously.

TV Shit-- the extended cut!

Uhmmm their worst album to me is probably Washing Machine. Dunno, something about it bugs me, though it does have The Diamond Sea which is one of the best songs ever made by anyone.

I love WM!!!! True love!

Worst: Rather Ripped. Hands down.

The Least Good
is Rather Ripped without a doubt
or TV Shit but it's hardly an album.
To it doesn't count at all.

TV Shit's way better than Rather Ripped.

One day you will all grow up and put RR in perspective instead of hating it just because it's a recent SY release.

News flash:
Most fans hate the most recent release by an artist the most. They become so familiar with their older material, they set unrealistic expectations which cannot possibly be met. It's how the human mind works.

Hey I actually like RR so I dunno who you're talking to Marty McFly

o I really LIKE RR, but i actually WORSHIP any of their other LPs so, there.
just answering the question.

are you worshiping the eternal already?

I've never heard of this. I thought most fans hated the shittiest releases by an artist the most? I stand corrected.

pretty much yes.
this band never ceases to amaze me.

Man, what world do you live in? It happens with virtually every single band. "THIS NEW ALBUM SUCKS!" I've never seen it not happen, really. Fans are really fickle and strange.

I dunno. I guess the fans of most of the bands I listen to -- the ones almost no one talks about on this increasingly-shitty board -- aren't so closeminded to dismiss an album a few hours after it comes out... they typically realize you actually need to listen to music a few times to let it sink in. Strange, eh?

It's kinda sad when last.fm users who primarily post their feelings about music on band's shoutboxes make the majority of the people posting on here recently seem mature in comparison.

News Flash:

..god I do not like you >.>

:fuckyou:

He may be directing that rude and bizarre comment at me. Feel free to keep the middle finger post, though... I'm sure he'll start a new thread about it soon.

Adam:
You'll notice it loads on last.fm

I'm not saying you guys dislike RR for that reason, but it undoubtedly happens a lot in this age of "now now now". Case in point: Quaristice

Rather Ripped is a meh album. Quite thoroughly meh that it almost defines meh.

I can't say it is the worst because it's just so meh.

I think Dirty has the title but I got rid of that so I can't quickly re-evaluate.

haha

starting the eternal for my fourth time in a row

Well, again, maybe we're not going to the same shoutboxes.

Never heard any Quarastice hatred except on this board. I thought everyone agreed it was a strong album. I think Autechre just gets better with every release, personally (with Draft being my personal favorite).

yeah holy fuck the eternal is definitely a grower for me

sacred trickster is gonna melt my face off live i can tell

The one that really gets me on the Eternal is "Leaky Lifeboat". I have listened to that song alone quite a few times. It's brilliant. I like the whole album, but that one really gets me for some reason. It's not just the harmonics.

hmm interesting. thats by far the one ive been having the most trouble enjoying. coming up next though

I've been hanging around WATMM a bit more lately and all I read on the Autechre board is fans whining about Quaristice being shit. If Autechre released an album of white noise as a follow up, I can imagine perspectives will change.

I think perspective has a lot to do with how much one enjoys an album. There was a lot of complaining about Sonic Nurse until RR came out.

Maybe you're onto something. I think we're mainly talking about musicians that are pretty popular though.

Perhaps people give more of "the benefit of the doubt" to smaller bands. Like, you never heard a super obscure noise release coming out and someone going "MAN IT JUST DIDN'T HAVE AS MUCH HARSH STATIC AS THE LAST ALBUM!" For whatever reason, it seems that people into, uh, "smaller" and more "out-there" music is often less critical of the music that bands make. Of course, it's a completely different atmosphere, as those bands may release something 2 or 3 times a year compared to Sonic Youth, who release a new album every 2/3 years.

So, yeah, I guess it has more to do with the build up, the anticipation of the release. My solution is just not to get excited about anything. Maybe that's why I actually enjoy the Eternal. I wasn't expecting much.

Yeah, I see what you mean with smaller bands. I remember when Battles released Mirrored and everyone loved it. Only months later was it trendy to hate it.

I'm not sure how it is possible to claim an album is the best or worst of a discography that spans 16 full length studio albums plus a tonne of side projects.....less than a DAY after hearing it for the first time. It's the worst form of internet attention seeking, and it works every time.

uh huh

confusion is sex for me.

omg you!!! :mad:
you!!

:mad:

I don't think SY has a 'worst album'. But they have made albums I haven't fallen in love with: NYCG&F, A Thousand Leaves...

this is the only one album that I don't listen often.
I like live songs from it though.

Dirty fucking rules. chappel hill, wish fulfilment, JC, PURR, 100%, the record is awesome.


the worst SY record is Experimenta Jet Set Trash & No Star by A MILE

I agree about Dirty, a powerful record start to finish. Over-bashed for sure. I saw them play it live and it was a sight & sound fury. I completely disagree with XJST&NS. First off, the packaging is cool as f. Secondly, listen carefully to the bass lines, they are masterful. The only drawback to this record is the absence of a Lee track.

Experimental Jetset is an album I severely don't like.

EJST&NS is the only sonic youth album, EP, side project, solo record I do not enjoy.