Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Worst Sonic Youth Song Poll! (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=7838)

Richard Pryor on Fire 11.08.2006 10:18 AM

Worst Sonic Youth Song Poll!
 
Bubblegum just sucks.

sonicl 11.08.2006 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Richard Pryor on Fire
Bubblegum just sucks.

But it's not an SY song, it's a cover version.

Panty Lies sucks. So does Washing Machine. And Junkies Promise.

RanaldoNecro 11.08.2006 10:49 AM

What is it that you don't like about Bubblegum?

I always thought it was interesting.....What do you think the band was shootiong for with that tune?

Everyneurotic 11.08.2006 10:57 AM

dare to insult kim fowley and prepare to live scorned and pointed in your life.

Toxa 11.08.2006 11:35 AM

They dont have bad songs

but I always skip drunken butterfly, kool thing and pattern recognition

GravitySlips 11.08.2006 12:00 PM

My Friend Goo

Trasher02 11.08.2006 01:28 PM

Plastic sun rules.
Fuck.

h8kurdt 11.08.2006 02:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
But it's not an SY song, it's a cover version.

Panty Lies sucks. So does Washing Machine. And Junkies Promise.


Oh you did not just diss Washing Machine! From 3 minutes onwards it is pure brilliance.

zedius 11.08.2006 02:16 PM

I chose other because Nic Fit is horrible.

HaydenAsche 11.08.2006 02:17 PM

Most of the songs on Rather Ripped are terrible.
Same goes for Nurse.
Plastic Sun is a borefest.
Panty Lies is terrible.

The worst, by far, is still Junkie's Promise.

pantophobia 11.08.2006 02:18 PM

where's jennthebenn

i am suprised she isn't already shitting on Small Flowers Crack Concrete, which she has rewritten many times, and most of the lyrics are better then what thurston did

for me, Tokyo Eye is the worst, all of Jet Set's problem's are due to the lack of great Thurston songs (Starfield Road, Waist, and In The Mind of the Bourgeois Reader aside), he really took his best and put them on Psychic Hearts

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GravitySlips
My Friend Goo


what????

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl

Panty Lies sucks. So does Washing Machine. And Junkies Promise.


we dont often disagree but
what???????
WHAT???????????????? AND
WHAT THE?????????????????????????????

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zedius
I chose other because Nic Fit is horrible.


AGAIN NOT AN SY SONG, ITS A COVER BY IAN MACKAYES OLD BAND THE UNTOUCHABLES.............
thurston always regretted not rerecording that song with proper vocals. that was just a one take jam think i believe that ended up on dirty......

jennthebenn 11.08.2006 03:46 PM

i'm here, just got off work.

small flowers crack concrete is so fucking hideous. thurston trying to do the beat thing NO; lee trying to do it, YES. lee has the voice to pull it off. i'm not sure how thurston is able to read his poetry aloud and not immediately smash a beer bottle over his own head.

small flowers crack concrete
elusive monastery the nyc sex kitten delight
lydia patti and richard a ct boy dream
bearded ginsberg text marijuana

it just goes on like that!

tokyo eye i'm still not sure why you dislike that so intently. it's better than
bourgeois, and damnit that song has thurston shrieking "hop" repeatedly.
which i do adore.

junkie's promise is just blah; self-obsessed and sexxee and androgynous
mind, i really appreciate thurston's sentiments, but they're couched in such
dull tracks. starfield road kinda singlehandedly saves thurston on jet set.

greenlight 11.08.2006 03:48 PM

i'm skipping little trouble girl always i'm listening to wm, but wm is just great great.

k-krack 11.08.2006 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656
AGAIN NOT AN SY SONG, ITS A COVER BY IAN MACKAYES OLD BAND THE UNTOUCHABLES.............
thurston always regretted not rerecording that song with proper vocals. that was just a one take jam think i believe that ended up on dirty......


Right you are. It says that in the deluxe edition liner notes.

I want to vote for My Friend Goo, 'cos the lyrics are shameful... Whatever, I will.

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:50 PM

none of the songs mentioned above are awful in my opinion.....

the worst sy tracks for me are contre le sexisme (worst opener ever)
tokyo eye (the song just lacks something, like the album i suppose)
reena (just dont really get it),
lightning (just found it out of place on nyc g&f),
dripping dream,
the neutral,
there is more but cant think

plastic sun rules
washing machine is a gem
streamxsonic subway is thurston in art teacher mode, it rocks
bubblegum is what it says, fun!
panty lies is great ate ate ate ate!

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by greenlight
i'm skipping little trouble girl always i'm listening to wm, but wm is just great great.


thats the little fucker i forgot. yep dont like it, maybe because it was played to death everywhere when wm came out. the only festering pimple on a porecelain doll face of an album

Daddylikes 11.08.2006 03:53 PM

Panty Lies Sucks!

Junkie's Promise Sucks!

Small Flowers Rules!

Daddylikes 11.08.2006 03:55 PM

hahahaha Reena blows butthole (as does most of the new album).

She keeps me blowing goats again!

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 03:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jennthebenn
man, you typed reena and i went HOW? and then you put dripping dream
and i shrieked! then when you put the neutral i knew that i could not
go on! okay, i'm being silly, but DAMN, those are some great songs. i
actually like all the songs you mentioned on both lists, heh.


hey, thats what cool about sy. opinions can vary greatly!!!!
some of sy best songs have bbeen recorded in this decade some were recorded in the early years so there is a lot to argue about!

Spiritual Amnesia 11.08.2006 04:36 PM

the two worst SY songs are
Unmade Bed & Little Trouble Girl

GravitySlips 11.08.2006 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656
what????


Sorry, but I find the chorus to be abominable. I normally do like Kim's voice (although she's my least fav. SY vocalist), but she really sounds like shit on this chorus. And the lyrics are dreadful too.

PAULYBEE2656 11.08.2006 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GravitySlips
Sorry, but I find the chorus to be abominable. I normally do like Kim's voice (although she's my least fav. SY vocalist), but she really sounds like shit on this chorus. And the lyrics are dreadful too.


ha! ok we beg to differ i reckon!!! i think its a classic song. totally groovy totally rockin and yeah kims vocals arent great but she aint the greatest singer ever with all due respects. i think its a fun tune but there is the proof in my arguement from my last post!!!

please people dont take my responses to heart (or anyones) its just opinions and we are all full of em!!!!

mushmanski57@hotmail.com 11.08.2006 06:51 PM

Out of that list, My Friend Goo is the worst, and may be the worst SY track in general. There really aren't too many I hate though... others are:

Starfield Road (I know everyone will give me shit for this)
The Neutral
Secret Girls (sometimes I enjoy it)
The Ineffable Me (see above thing about Secret Girls)
Total Trash (should be a bit shorter, I like it when they extend songs, but seems useless here)

Plastic Sun and Panty Lies do NOT suck!

_slavo_ 11.09.2006 08:44 AM

I can't stand Creme Brulee, Nic Fit, Plastic Sun and Arthur Doyle Hand Creme.

The often dissed Panty Lies belongs to one of my favourite SY songs :)

PAULYBEE2656 11.09.2006 09:43 AM

creme brulee... forgot about that one.. says it all really

nicfit 11.09.2006 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by _slavo_
I can't stand Creme Brulee, Nic Fit, Plastic Sun and Arthur Doyle Hand Creme.

The often dissed Panty Lies belongs to one of my favourite SY songs :)


BUAHAAAA! slavo_ hates me!
back to the topic, in the list i'd choose my friend goo...

nneureiter 11.09.2006 12:13 PM

Oh man, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I cannot believe someone put Unmade Bed. That might be in my list of fav's from any band.

PAULYBEE2656 11.09.2006 01:50 PM

unmade bed is a great song alright but i cant get over the hatred for my friend goo.....

finding nobody 11.09.2006 02:58 PM

Im not fond of Junkie's Promise

habibtheantiamericanbitch 11.09.2006 03:19 PM

what the hell is so bad about Renegade Princess???? One of my favorite high volume, shout along songs......after Mack The Knife, of course.......

Danny Himself 11.09.2006 06:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jennthebenn
small flowers crack concrete
elusive monastery the nyc sex kitten delight
lydia patti and richard a ct boy dream
bearded ginsberg text marijuana

it just goes on like that!


Ahahaha! Great!

evollove 11.09.2006 06:57 PM

For some reason SY has to have 1 bad song on an otherwise great record. Why? I think to give contrast. "Getting used to the genius? Here's something that sucks. Now, isn't the good stuff even better?"

Or, a Zen-ish thing maybe, like there can't be perfection without imperfection.

But yeah, Bubblegum fucks up EVOL
Hotwire My Heart fucks up SISTER
My Freind Goo doesn't exactly fuck up GOO, but it doesn't help
Pantie Lies...I'm not sure I've heard it all the way through more than once or twice, I hate it so much, for some reason
Ineffible Me is a low point on the brilliant T Leaves

Latley, since the genius isn't flowing as wildly as it did before, there's less reason to have that seemingly obligitory shitty song. My own opinion here, but Sonic Nurse was too mediocre to be able to include something as shitty as Panty Lies, if that makes any sense.

Junkie's promise, by the way, is one of those remarkable songs that can rock so fucking hard at a moderatly slow pace. Heavy, heavy stuff, man.

I've never got sick of Kool Thing, and, after 15 years, doesn't seem like I will.

PAULYBEE2656 11.10.2006 05:05 AM

Ineffible Me is a low point on the brilliant T Leaves- its not that bad!!!!

i agree with junkies promise tho. wicked song

_slavo_ 11.10.2006 05:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nicfit
BUAHAAAA! slavo_ hates me!
back to the topic, in the list i'd choose my friend goo...


naaah mate
lots of love
lots of love!

porkmarras 11.10.2006 05:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
But it's not an SY song, it's a cover version.

Panty Lies sucks. So does Washing Machine. And Junkies Promise.

:o :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

ZEROpumpkins 11.10.2006 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
So does Washing Machine. And Junkies Promise.

WHOAH! WHOAH! Appreciate Washing Machine for the Jam and Junkies Promise for the chorus. Yes, Panty Lies sucks.

porkmarras 11.10.2006 05:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porkmarras
:o :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

....:p


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth