Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Nevermind (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=29216)

uhler 02.02.2009 06:52 PM

great album.

1. bleach
2. in utero
3. nevermind
thats my order of nirvana's albums.

Toilet & Bowels 02.02.2009 07:35 PM

although as much as a turning point as this album was for me i've probably listened to it about 5 times in the last 10 years

joe11121 02.02.2009 07:54 PM

Good album, I still think the unplugged was their best. Then In Utero

[Sandbag] 02.02.2009 08:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe11121
Good album, I still think the unplugged was their best. Then In Utero


i agree... the unplugged...it's sublime

noisereductions 02.02.2009 08:07 PM

Would I have preferred a better (worse) production sound? Sure. But when all is done and said, it's a record of great songs beginning to end.

GeneticKiss 02.02.2009 08:10 PM

My fave is Incesticide. Not really an album per se, but a great collection of some of their best work.

Each Nirvana album has pros and cons:

Bleach:
+ Some awesome riffs
+ Even the heavier songs are catchy
- Chad Channing just does not carry the band like Dave Grohl
- Lacks depth in some ways

Nevermind:
+ Greater variety in songs
+/- Gave alternative rock mainstream credibility
- Overproduced in parts

In Utero:
+ Kurt's rawest lyrics
+ Polarized feel actually works well
- Muddled production in parts

atsonicpark 02.03.2009 05:22 AM

There's like 3 good songs on Nevermind. What a predictable, boring, shitty little record. Can't deny its "importance" though it's EASILY Nirvana's worst.

sarramkrop 02.03.2009 05:26 AM

I still think it's a great record. I don't care about the aftermath, nor I listen to it much anymore. It's a great record by a great band which means a lot to me, that's all. If I was so concerned about the things that concern atsonicpark so much, I'd hate everything.

atsonicpark 02.03.2009 05:46 AM

I just don't think it's that special and has never in my life struck me as anything that great, even when I was a kid. I loved In Utero a lot more 15 or so years ago and nowadays I think FROM THE MUDDY BANKS is their best album...

sarramkrop 02.03.2009 05:56 AM

It was a special record by a special band. Why do you seem concerned about it? Do you not like it when something is special?

atsonicpark 02.03.2009 06:11 AM

Okay.

SonicBebs 02.03.2009 08:44 AM

loved it to bits at the time.
When this came up last i listened again and side 2 is pretty good but side 1, i know the songs inside out and it didn't excite me. still love the album for everything it means rather than just the music.

and

In Utero
Incesticide
Bleach
Nevermind

lechaoscestmoi 02.03.2009 09:11 AM

nevermind
incesticide
in utero
bleach

[Sandbag] 02.03.2009 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneticKiss
Each Nirvana album has pros and cons:

Bleach:
- Chad Channing just does not carry the band like Dave Grohl


fuckin true... grohl keeps a beat and helps marking the parts of the songs... channing is more like a mess of drumrolls and stuff.. but i guess it worked well for bleach

atsonicpark 02.03.2009 09:36 AM

This album makes me want to listen to Killing Joke.

Also, "Drain You" really is a brilliant song.

lechaoscestmoi 02.03.2009 09:54 AM

best song on that album, yes.

[Sandbag] 02.03.2009 09:57 AM

theres this part in 'endless nameless' that sounds like... sonic youth.. the quiet bit. love it.

Green_mind 02.03.2009 12:22 PM

In bloom is such an ace song to bash out on the drums, great fun. I made a tune on my guitar a few days ago, but I worry that it sounds slightly similar to the come as you are :eek:

The Lung 02.03.2009 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
There's like 3 good songs on Nevermind. What a predictable, boring, shitty little record. Can't deny its "importance" though it's EASILY Nirvana's worst.


Although I usually respect your opinions this post makes you sound like a whining little cunt.

The record becomes predictable and boring after you've heard it a 100 times but I'll never forget the feeling I used to get from it when it was fresh.

atsonicpark 02.03.2009 12:51 PM

Um, no, I'm not referring to listening to it 100 times, I'm referring to listening to it the first time and hearing nearly every verse-chorus-verse-chorus-guitar solo that follows the melody of the verses exactly-chorus song with a few variations here or there (but no MAJOR variations except perhaps the middle of "Drain You" and the acoustic songs). I have no problem with simple songs, and the same structure is prevalent in most Nirvana songs, but this album in particular has nothing creative going on in it except the riff in "Come As You Are" (which is a Killing Joke ripoff!) and the middle of "Drain You" and the cello in "Something in the Way". The star of the album is definitely Krist, who has some really neat bass lines here or there, and that bass distortion on "Breed" is awesome. I just find most of the riffs and songs kinda bland and dull, first listen or 100th listen, with a few exceptions.

In Utero is half an amazing album and half THE WORST SHIT NIRVANA HAS EVER RECORDED ("Rape Me"?! "Pennyroyal Tea"? "Tourette's"? All awful). Good thing the good shit is really good.

Bleach has some truly brilliant songs; so raw and nasty. That riff in "Negative Creep"... what is that? Noisey, grungey (!), a great little record.

Incesticide is b-sides and throwaways, yet somehow it's their most interesting record! Has my favorite Nirvana song on it, "Aneurysm".

Always was indifferent towards Unplugged in New York. Just don't think most of the songs work acoustically. As much as I usually jack off for the sound of guitars with holes in them, this is a dull record.

Live from the Muddy Banks of the Wishkah is awesome, except for "Heart-Shaped Box" (which I always hated) and a few other stinkers. It's got some awesome fucking songs on it; the DEFINITIVE version of "Aneurysm" and "Spank Thru" which is amongst my favorite Nirvana songs.

With the Lights Out has some truly awful shit that should've never have seen the light of day but it has some great stuff too, like "Marigold" (which had been released before but...).

Nirvana's a pretty good band, and I enjoy watching their live videos more than listening to their records.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:00 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth