Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   What's the rarest song you've seen SY play live? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=2157)

marleypumpkin 05.24.2006 01:17 AM

What's the rarest song you've seen SY play live?
 
When I saw them in '04, they didn't play anything unusual, just some golden oldies, & stuff off "Sonic Nurse". & I was wondering if any of you have seen SY play anything rare that they usually don't play live?

silverfreepress (sdasher) 05.24.2006 01:24 AM

the Mildred Pierce they did in Boston was a few and far between performance.
Date: Monday, April 23rd, 2001
City: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Venue: The Roxy
SET LIST
She Is Not Alone
Bull in the Heather
Free City Rhymes
Nevermind
Side2Side
Drunken Butterfly
Hoarfrost
Schizophrenia
Small Flowers Crack Concrete
Kool Thing
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Mildred Pierce
Teenage Riot



the theatre has these gold lions bookending the stage.

jennthebenn 05.24.2006 01:26 AM

"inhuman", irving plaza, 11/30/02...they don't bust that one out too much these days.

if you want REAL rare, though...11/24/02, at the recher theatre in baltimore, they ran through a brief rendition of the already-brief half japanese classic "calling all girls" ("maryland's finest", thurston proclaimed).

CHOUT 05.24.2006 01:28 AM

Well, rare for me in the 9 times I've seen them was Death Valley 69.

krastian 05.24.2006 01:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jennthebenn
"
if you want REAL rare, though...11/24/02, at the recher theatre in baltimore, they ran through a brief rendition of the already-brief half japanese classic "calling all girls" ("maryland's finest", thurston proclaimed).

Holla. I was there:D. Good call jenn. Yeah CHOUT I was thinking Death Valley too....pretty rare I reckon.

krastian 05.24.2006 01:44 AM

Damn Kegmama, I would have killed to see that 95 set.

krastian 05.24.2006 02:02 AM

I thought that was the one.

SubSonicPumpAction 05.24.2006 02:06 AM

kegmama you and I have been to the same shows pretty much. Did you see them when they play at the wilshire theatre?
s

Jef Mertens 05.24.2006 02:12 AM

2001: the carpenter's piece for piano from george maciunas. They nailed that piano June 10th in Gent Belgium.
I don't know how many piano's they wrecked on their goodbye tour but I wreckon not a lot.

connie kreski 05.24.2006 02:19 AM

shaking hell, last time in paris @ le nouveau casino...

marleypumpkin 05.24.2006 02:32 AM

Man, I'm jealous! Especially of kegmama.

Seeing Bikini Kill & SY @ the same show must have been life changing. & I agree, SY is the best live band ever.

dazedcola 05.24.2006 02:46 AM

they did a real amazing version of "burning spear" as a set opener the last time they were in boston.

noiseball 05.24.2006 03:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kegmama

Tom Violence


White Kross





huh?

aren't these like two of the songs they play most often?
if not THE two they play most often???!

sonicl 05.24.2006 03:37 AM

October 16th, 1988
The Astoria, London, England

Teenage Riot
Hey Joni
The Wonder
Hyperstation
'Cross the Breeze
Candle
Kissability
Eric's Trip
I Love Her All The Time
The Sprawl
Brother James
Eliminator Jr.
--
Silver Rocket
Tunafish is a Favorite Dish
Confusion is Next
Counting Song
(The two oddball encore tunes are the band jamming while Thurston makes up lyrics)


March 22nd, 1989
Kilburn National Ballroom, London, England


Set list unknown...


September 10th, 1990
Brixton Academy, London, England

Tom Violence
Eric's Trip
Cinderella's Big Score
Stereo Sanctity
Flower
Kill Yr Idols
Tunic
Dirty Boots
Mary Christ
Kool Thing
White Cross
Mote
My Friend Goo
The Bedroom
Silver Rocket
Confusion is Next


April 19th, 1996
Forum, London, England

Skink
Bull in the Heather
Starfield Road
Washing Machine
Junkie's Promise
Eric's Trip
Becuz
Panty Lies
100%
PCH
Skip Tracer
Diamond Sea
--
Unwind
Sugar Kane


June 29th, 1998
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Anagrama
Sunday
Female Mechanic
Karen Koltrane
The Ineffable Me
Hits of Sunshine
French Tickler
Hoarfrost
Wildflower Soul
Heather Angel
--
Stil
Shadow of a Doubt
Death Valley 69


July 1st, 1998
Royal Festival Hall, London, England

Anagrama
Sunday
Female Mechanic
Karen Koltrane
Wildflower Soul
French Tickler
Hits of Sunshine
Ineffable Me
Hoarfrost
Heather Angel


July 1st, 2000
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Schizophrenia
Burning Spear
Free City Rhymes
Renegade Princess
Kool Thing
Hoarfrost
Nevermind
Side2Side
White Kross
Bull in the Heather
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Lightnin'
100%


June 16th, 2001
Royal Festival Hall, London, England

Having Never Written a Note for Percussion
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 1 - Against the Wind)
Six
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 2 - Against the Wall)
Treatise
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 3 - Against the Sky)
Burdocks
Clapping Music
Four6
She Is Not Alone
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Piano Piece #13
Side2Side


June 24th, 2002
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Kotton Krown
Bull in the Heather
The Empty Page
Eric's Trip
Rain on Tin
Plastic Sun
Kissability
Karenology
Candle
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style
Drunken Butterfly
Sympathy for the Strawberry
--
Disconnection Notice
Kool Thing
--
Making The Nature Scene


2 September, 2004
Brixton Academy, London, England

I Love You Golden Blue
Stones
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Eric's Trip
Teenage Riot
New Hampshire
Mariah Carey
Paper Cup Exit
Dude Ranch Nurse
Brother James
--
PCH
Expressway


October 2005
Cite de la Musique, Paris, France


Set list: I can't remember, but it included the only-played-twice cover of John Lennon's "Isolation"


I guess that Tunafish is a Favorite Dish and Counting Song from my very first concert and Isolation from Paris laast year are my number one rarities.

toxic johnny 05.24.2006 04:21 AM

Halloween, March 20th, 1985 London, ICA.
The Good And The Bad, March 23rd, 1985 Thames Poly.
(She's In A) Bad Mood' jam, November 8th, 1985 (Afternoon Show) Brighton beach
Marilyn Moore, May 5th, 1986 Brighton Beach.
Death to our Friends, May 23rd, 1986 London ULU.
I Wanna Be Your Dog w/ Iggy Pop, June 4th, 1987 London, Town and Country Club.
Tunafish is a Favorite Dish, Counting Song, October 16th, 1988 London, The Astoria.
The Bedroom, September 10th, 1990 London, Brixton Academy.
Genetic, December 14th, 1992 London, Brixton Academy.
Bone, April 18th, 1996 London, The Forum.
Anagrama + Stil, June 29th, 1998 London, Shepherds Bush Empire.
Having Never Written a Note for Percussion
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 1 - Against the Wind)
Six
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 2 - Against the Wall)
Treatise
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 3 - Against the Sky)
Burdocks
Clapping Music
Four6
Piano Piece #13, June 16th, 2001 London, Royal Festival Hall.

marleypumpkin 05.24.2006 04:25 AM

^:
All 3 "Voice Piece For Soprano"'s had to be an absolute masterpiece.

Bow down to Toxic Johnny!

sonicl 05.24.2006 04:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by toxic johnny
Halloween, March 20th, 1985 London, ICA.
The Good And The Bad, March 23rd, 1985 Thames Poly.
(She's In A) Bad Mood' jam, November 8th, 1985 (Afternoon Show) Brighton beach
Marilyn Moore, May 5th, 1986 Brighton Beach.
Death to our Friends, May 23rd, 1986 London ULU.
I Wanna Be Your Dog w/ Iggy Pop, June 4th, 1987 London, Town and Country Club.
Tunafish is a Favorite Dish, Counting Song, October 16th, 1988 London, The Astoria.
The Bedroom, September 10th, 1990 London, Brixton Academy.
Genetic, December 14th, 1992 London, Brixton Academy.
Bone, April 18th, 1996 London, The Forum.
Anagrama + Stil, June 29th, 1998 London, Shepherds Bush Empire.
Having Never Written a Note for Percussion
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 1 - Against the Wind)
Six
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 2 - Against the Wall)
Treatise
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 3 - Against the Sky)
Burdocks
Clapping Music
Four6
Piano Piece #13, June 16th, 2001 London, Royal Festival Hall.


Stoopid fucken thing won't let me rep you. Says I've gotta rep some other people first.

whorefrost 05.24.2006 07:22 AM

making the nature scene

PunkerViolence 05.24.2006 07:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
October 16th, 1988
The Astoria, London, England

Teenage Riot
Hey Joni
The Wonder
Hyperstation
'Cross the Breeze
Candle
Kissability
Eric's Trip
I Love Her All The Time
The Sprawl
Brother James
Eliminator Jr.
--
Silver Rocket
Tunafish is a Favorite Dish
Confusion is Next
Counting Song
(The two oddball encore tunes are the band jamming while Thurston makes up lyrics)


March 22nd, 1989
Kilburn National Ballroom, London, England


Set list unknown...


September 10th, 1990
Brixton Academy, London, England

Tom Violence
Eric's Trip
Cinderella's Big Score
Stereo Sanctity
Flower
Kill Yr Idols
Tunic
Dirty Boots
Mary Christ
Kool Thing
White Cross
Mote
My Friend Goo
The Bedroom
Silver Rocket
Confusion is Next


April 19th, 1996
Forum, London, England

Skink
Bull in the Heather
Starfield Road
Washing Machine
Junkie's Promise
Eric's Trip
Becuz
Panty Lies
100%
PCH
Skip Tracer
Diamond Sea
--
Unwind
Sugar Kane


June 29th, 1998
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Anagrama
Sunday
Female Mechanic
Karen Koltrane
The Ineffable Me
Hits of Sunshine
French Tickler
Hoarfrost
Wildflower Soul
Heather Angel
--
Stil
Shadow of a Doubt
Death Valley 69


July 1st, 1998
Royal Festival Hall, London, England

Anagrama
Sunday
Female Mechanic
Karen Koltrane
Wildflower Soul
French Tickler
Hits of Sunshine
Ineffable Me
Hoarfrost
Heather Angel


July 1st, 2000
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Schizophrenia
Burning Spear
Free City Rhymes
Renegade Princess
Kool Thing
Hoarfrost
Nevermind
Side2Side
White Kross
Bull in the Heather
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Lightnin'
100%


June 16th, 2001
Royal Festival Hall, London, England

Having Never Written a Note for Percussion
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 1 - Against the Wind)
Six
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 2 - Against the Wall)
Treatise
Voice Piece for Soprano (pt 3 - Against the Sky)
Burdocks
Clapping Music
Four6
She Is Not Alone
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Piano Piece #13
Side2Side


June 24th, 2002
Shepherds Bush Empire, London, England

Kotton Krown
Bull in the Heather
The Empty Page
Eric's Trip
Rain on Tin
Plastic Sun
Kissability
Karenology
Candle
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style
Drunken Butterfly
Sympathy for the Strawberry
--
Disconnection Notice
Kool Thing
--
Making The Nature Scene


2 September, 2004
Brixton Academy, London, England

I Love You Golden Blue
Stones
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Eric's Trip
Teenage Riot
New Hampshire
Mariah Carey
Paper Cup Exit
Dude Ranch Nurse
Brother James
--
PCH
Expressway


October 2005
Cite de la Musique, Paris, France


Set list: I can't remember, but it included the only-played-twice cover of John Lennon's "Isolation"


I guess that Tunafish is a Favorite Dish and Counting Song from my very first concert and Isolation from Paris laast year are my number one rarities.


Wow fuck, those are cool. Idve liked to've seen them in 88' but i wasnt even born then.

FruitLoop 05.24.2006 09:44 AM

Date: Wednesday, August 14th, 2002
City: Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Venue: Le Medley

Candle
Bull in the Heather
The Empty Page
Skip Tracer
Plastic Sun
Rain on Tin
Kissability
Karenology
Shadow of a Doubt
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style
Sympathy for the Strawberry
100%
--
Disconnection Notice
Silver Rocket
--
Kool Thing

Kissability and Skip Tracer on the same night... that was sweet (not to mention Rain on Tin live...)
Didn't post the show I saw on the Nurse tour, pretty dull setlist imo. There was this girl that flashed a sing saying "wish fulfilment please!" to Lee before the set, but no such luck.

CHOUT 05.24.2006 12:11 PM

Here's the sets that I've seen

9/30/92 First Avenue Minneapolis

Shoot
Kool Thing
100%
Purr
Swimsuit Issue
Theresa's Soundworld
Youth Against Fascism
Genetic
Sugar Kane
Orange Rolls, Angel's Spit
Drunken Butterfly
--
JC
Expressway

5/29/95 First Avenue Minneapolis
Skink
Tom Violence
Self-Obsessed and Sexxee
Bull in the Heather
Starfield Road
Washing Machine
No Queen Blues
Becuz
Saucer-Like
Unwind
Candle
Diamond Sea
--
Junkie's Promise
Panty Lies
Waist
Schizophrenia

5/30/95 Target Center Minneapolis
Tom Violence
Bull in the Heather
Starfield Road
Washing Machine
No Queen Blues
Skip Tracer
Diamond Sea

10/30/95 First Avenue Minneapolis
Skink
Teenage Riot
Candle
Becuz
Saucer-Like
Junkie's Promise
Tom Violence
Bull in the Heather
Starfield Road
Washing Machine
No Queen Blues
Diamond Sea
--
Eric's Trip
Expressway

5/17/98 O'Shaugnessy Auditorium St. Paul
Karen Koltrane
Female Mechanic
Sunday
Anagrama
Hits Of Sunshine
The Ineffable Me
Hoarfrost
French Tickler
Wildflower Soul
Heather Angel
--
Stil
Death Valley '69


6/09/00 Walker, Minneapolis

Teenage Riot
Free City Rhymes
Renegade Princess
Kool Thing
Nevermind (What Was It Anyway)
Side 2 Side
Mote
Tom Violence
White Kross
NYC Ghosts & Flowers
--
Lightnin'
Schizophrenia

8/19/02 First Avenue Minneapolis
Candle
Kissability
The Empty Page
Rain on Tin
Mote
Plastic Sun
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style
Shadow of a Doubt
Karenology
Drunken Butterfly
Sympathy for the Strawberry
Schizophrenia
--
Disconnection Notice
Tom Violence
--
Making the Nature Scene

7/28/04 The Quest Minneapolis
I Love You Golden Blue
Empty Page
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Eric's Trip
Mariah Carey and the Arthur Doyle Hand Cream
Stones
New Hampshire
Paper Cup Exit
Tom Violence
Dude Ranch Nurse
Drunken Butterfly
--
Peace Attack
PCH
--
Shadow of a Doubt

7/3/04 The Rave Milwaukee
Rain on Tin
Schizophrenia
I Love You Golden Blue
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Karenology
Mariah Carey...
Stones
New Hampshire
Paper Cup Exit
Dude Ranch Nurse
Brother James
--
Shadow of a Doubt
Sugar Kane
--
Teenage Riot

Evaluating these, most of what are rare weren't at the time - new songs off
new albums that don't get played much anymore. Or old songs that got played
frequently on particular tours. It's all relative I guess.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 05.24.2006 01:51 PM

Pittsburgh 2003

Bull in the Heather
The Empty Page
Catholic Block
Rain on Tin
Plastic Sun
Karenology
Shadow of a Doubt
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style
Mariah Carey and the Arthur Doyle Hand Cream
Mote
Drunken Butterfly
Sympathy for the Strawberry
--
Disconnection Notice
Sugar Kane
--
Teenage Riot

Nothing rare, but a good set never the less. Although they only played mote 4 times that tour. I can't remember the setlist from 2004 Cleveland, but I remember they played rain on tin, everything from nurse, and some other stuff too.

createsounds 05.24.2006 04:22 PM

yeah ........ they dont play a very wide range of their own songs .. usually only about 25 in rotation .....
so prolly the only rare thing i saw was on the nurse tour when ... sy, wolf eyes, and hair police all rioted on "inhuman"... although it seamed like more of a big joke than it was about the music .... unfortunately ...



it would be cool if sy were to play sets of there new songs and then different old ones evry night .. instead of the new ones and then the same 6 or 7 oldies over and over again in a pretty steady rotation .........

HaydenAsche 05.24.2006 04:36 PM

Lawl. I have seen SY play the entire Either/Or album in order with an encore of "Hives Hives". Good show.

krastian 05.24.2006 04:38 PM

Sike

krastian 05.24.2006 05:10 PM

Yes sir.

krastian 05.24.2006 05:18 PM

Nah, I can't draw with a mouse.

HaydenAsche 05.24.2006 05:25 PM

and HOMOSEXUALS.

Pax Americana 05.24.2006 05:40 PM

8/7/04 Buffalo, NY: The Sphere

I Love You Golden Blue
Stones
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Eric's Trip
Mariah Carey
Empty Page
Paper Cup Exit
Silver Rocket
New Hampshire
Dude Ranch Nurse
Sugar Kane
--
Rain on Tin
--
Expressway



Nothing really 'rare' I guess, though the older songs they did play I was real happy with. Especially 'Eric's Trip' and 'Expressway'.




marleypumpkin 05.24.2006 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pax Americana
8/7/04 Buffalo, NY: The Sphere

I Love You Golden Blue
Stones
Pattern Recognition
Unmade Bed
Eric's Trip
Mariah Carey
Empty Page
Paper Cup Exit
Silver Rocket
New Hampshire
Dude Ranch Nurse
Sugar Kane
--
Rain on Tin
--
Expressway



Nothing really 'rare' I guess, though the older songs they did play I was real happy with. Especially 'Eric's Trip' and 'Expressway'.


It seems like every show except The Orange Peel got a good, solid set-list.
(check the mustang site: August 20, 2004, The Orange Peel, Asheville, NC)

marleypumpkin 05.24.2006 07:46 PM

Yeah, I am jealous of that set-list.
Well, the reason I didn't think it was a "full" set is that I would have liked to heard more recent stuff (@ the time). Like, some songs off "Murray Street" would have been a highlight for me. Or, "A Thousand Leaves". I really did enjoy the early stuff they played, like PCH, & "Teenage Riot", I just thought they could have done a better set.

jennthebenn 05.24.2006 09:40 PM

they did play stones and sunday at a show earlier this year, at least...i'd
like to see both survive.

createsounds 05.25.2006 07:06 AM

they need to be able to paly ALL there songs ... not just a couple oldies.....
like a jam band ..
........ i mean jam bands sux but they put on the best shows, never any of the same songs two nights in a row and allways like three hour shows....

sonic youth should ditch the opening acts and play solo shows .. were they keep it real and play like a bunch of songs every night and have at least 2 full sets ......
AT VERY LEAST

h8kurdt 05.25.2006 07:34 AM

I agree they should have a variety of songs on their sets, have a broad spectrum guys.

I'm thinkin that ATP will just be another gig for SY ie/another gig to promote the new album.

Glice 05.25.2006 07:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by createsounds

sonic youth should ditch the opening acts and play solo shows .. were they keep it real and play like a bunch of songs every night and have at least 2 full sets ......
AT VERY LEAST


I don't think there's enough people would go and see that show. I might, but I would think quite a lot about it, and I'm a fairly heavy SY fan. Ok, so I'm not obsessive enough to go to every show, and I'm lucky enough to live somewhere where they play a couple of shows each album, if not a full tour.

And the support bands are nearly always top quality... especially Glenn Branca at the London RFH show... incidentally, I saw the soundcheck for that (sneaked in an hid somewhere)... they were doing soundy things and then a mostly instrumental she is not alone... that's not something many people saw (unless there were other people hiding as well).

porkmarras 05.25.2006 07:54 AM

Didnt they play a show at The Sheperd Bush Empire in London where they had VVM as a support act?I thought that was a cool choice for them.

Glice 05.25.2006 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porkmarras
Didnt they play a show at The Sheperd Bush Empire in London where they had VVM as a support act?I thought that was a cool choice for them.


Yeah... I didn't see that show, but I saw VVM a couple of years before that... they used to have a really confrontational and unpleasant live show, but the last time I saw them it was a bit tame and laptoppy... unfortunately, with that kind of music, if you don't have a good live show, the music can be super-boring. Would've been good to see the SY-supporting masses cower in fear though.

porkmarras 05.25.2006 08:29 AM

I've read a review of it somewhere and it seems like his stage set comprised of dead meat he'd buy from the local butcher wherever he was playing at the time and he would place it near his laptop onstage.These days he seems to be really into belgian beat stuff from the eighties wich he manages to make sound like a drive by shooting outside a Daltson primary school.His 'Sick Love'
album is still a gem after all these years.

sonicl 05.25.2006 08:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porkmarras
Didnt they play a show at The Sheperd Bush Empire in London where they had VVM as a support act?I thought that was a cool choice for them.

Yeah, I went to that one http://www.sonicyouth.com/mustang/cc/070100.html. They had two supports, the other one of which was Morphogenesis. Probably the most fucked up support line up I've ever come across. V/VM dressed in pig masks playing Mouldy Old Dough very loud and distorted, followed by a bunch of old men sitting at tables dragging chains across tabletop guitars. The Morphogenesis performance was recorded and is available on their In Streams Vol 2 CD. Please don't mistake that for a recommendation, it's just a statement of fact.

porkmarras 05.25.2006 08:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
Yeah, I went to that one [url=http://www.sonicyouth.com/mustang/cc/070100.html[/URL]. They had two supports, the other one of which was Morphogenesis. Probably the most fucked up support line up I've ever come across. V/VM dressed in pig masks playing Mouldy Old Dough very loud, followed by a bunch of old men sitting at tables playing dragging chains across tabletop guitars. The Morphogenesis performance was recorded and is available on their In Streams Vol 2 CD. Please don't mistake that for a recommendation, it's just a statement of fact.

WoW!!!Thank you sonicl


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth