Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   SY and Beck cover each other (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=29232)

noisereductions 04.20.2009 02:08 PM

I know! I figured "Pay No Mind" would be 1 of 2 things: Either a Thurstonish TREES/MURRAY ST faithful acoustic version, or a super noisy rawk version; but this was something else entirely. I think for the first half I was like "awe, what a letdown" but by the 2nd half I was like "OMG... I love SY soooo much!"

Danny Himself 04.20.2009 02:31 PM

I hated it, I think I still do, I only gave it a couple listens. Pay No Mind is one of my favourite songs and I think they just lazily butchered it, the pretentious twats.

Derek 04.20.2009 02:33 PM

Yeah, I thought it was extremely lazy as well.

noisereductions 04.20.2009 02:35 PM

It was lazy in an awesome way. Though, remember, I'm the one guy who's not in the band that LOVES "Eyes & Teeth".

noisereductions 04.20.2009 02:35 PM

PS, what makes "Pay No Mind" is Steve's beats.

RanaldoNecro 04.21.2009 01:24 AM

I was kinda dissapointed....

The original has such a strong quality.

dazedcola 04.22.2009 10:32 PM

I instantly loved the "green light" cover, it reminded me off something from his early folk period. I wish he'd go back to this style more.Its quite a feat to make a sonic youth song into a beautiful acoustic track.

On the otherside "pay no mind" was nothing what i expected. Its one of my favorite beck songs and i thought theyd do a version of it like they did "im not there". The first half is really deconstructed but then it got great with the noise part sounding like some prime EVOL material and ending with a Dirty kind of rock groove.

They should have pressed more copies of the single, I wasnt able to get one on record store day.

canabero 04.22.2009 10:37 PM

i heard Green Light by Beck and yeah is a fucking awesome version.

Rob Instigator 04.23.2009 08:37 AM

Beck's green light cover is fine. It sounds like a total toss-off though, recorded during studio down-time.

the Pay No Mind is very cool. I have not heard the original but I enjoyed the song for what it was.

noisereductions 04.23.2009 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
I have not heard the original



that's really surprising to me for some reason. I mean, it wasn't all over the radio or whatever, but it's sort of a signature tune. I'd be as surprised if somebody said "I've never heard 'Serve The Servents" or something like that.

Rob Instigator 04.23.2009 09:51 AM

i will chekc it out on the youtube.

Rob Instigator 04.23.2009 09:55 AM

Nope. never heard it before.
why do people complain about malkmus' lyrics being pointless and meaningless and not get on beck's ass about his non-sequitor lyrics? I wonder... so many questions.

mil_pl 04.23.2009 10:12 AM

no garage is anti-orgasm song from session.

noisereductions 04.23.2009 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
Nope. never heard it before.
why do people complain about malkmus' lyrics being pointless and meaningless and not get on beck's ass about his non-sequitor lyrics? I wonder... so many questions.



I love both of their lyrics, personally.

Rob Instigator 04.23.2009 01:26 PM

i like obfuscating lyrics too. the last thing I ussually want to hear is the "deep thoughts" of some cocksmear in a band

fugazifan 04.25.2009 04:41 AM

wow, becks version of green light is really good.
and i really dont like beck

fugazifan 04.25.2009 04:51 AM

i just heard pay no mind. i thought it was cool. i like hearing SY sing the folk tune over the feedback. it was nice to hear them sing in a different meter than what they usually sing in.
they should do more folk stuff

nicfit 04.25.2009 05:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fugazifan
i just heard pay no mind. i thought it was cool. i like hearing SY sing the folk tune over the feedback. it was nice to hear them sing in a different meter than what they usually sing in.
they should do more folk stuff


Yeah, like the singer-songwriter album by Lee :D.

wellcharge 04.25.2009 07:48 AM

the original pay no mind is the only beck song i'm familiar with(it's in a local skate video from my jr.high days haha) and i thought the sy cover was pretty much boring and pointless

haven't heard the greenlight cover but i'm looking forward to it

joe11121 04.25.2009 10:41 AM

I listened to Green Light & Pay No Mind on youtube.
Pay No Mind is pretty boring.
Green Light is pretty good though.

sl1ck 04.25.2009 10:52 AM

I really dig Beck's cover of "Green Light." The SY cover of "Pay No Mind" didn't do much for me though. "Pay No Mind" just doesn't translate very well with Sonic Youth's sound...I wonder why they choose "Pay No Mind" to cover.

toxic johnny 04.25.2009 03:17 PM

I am enjoying the Pay No Mind cover very much... it is pure deconstruction bliss.

StevOK 04.25.2009 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sl1ck
I wonder why they choose "Pay No Mind" to cover.


Probably because of the awesome lyrics.

sicsonic 04.25.2009 09:08 PM

the 'pay no mind' cover isn't horrible, but it would be so much better with just lee's vocals. normally i really don't mind kim's vocals, but it kinda brings this track down a bit.

pbradley 04.25.2009 10:09 PM

Sonic Youth covering Beck covering Bob Dylan!

Bollocks_to_Pop 05.06.2009 04:30 PM

Don't know legit this is, but I just read on a Beck blog this:

"Last November, Beck and his band covered on stage, “Star Power.” This is a Sonic Youth song from their album EVOL. A few months later, it was announced that Beck was releasing a cover of “Green Light,” which is also from EVOL. That release was a single, the b-side being a Sonic Youth cover of “Pay No Mind” no less! What does all this EVOLness mean? We learned today, thanks to our friends in Japan, that Beck has covered the whole album. He said this in an interview/article with a Japanese magazine. I’m told it will be part of some Sonic Youth box set. I know SY has been releasing Deluxe versions of their albums, so maybe EVOL Deluxe? Or maybe some greater box set project?
Regardless, this is super interesting and really a fun thing for Beck to have done!"

I personally really loved Beck's cover of Green Light so hopefully one day we might be able to here this. Since Moshe hasn't said anything about this or about an EVOL deluxe I'm not getting my hopes too up though. None the less I think both would be amazing.

dionysusundone 05.06.2009 06:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bollocks_to_Pop
Don't know legit this is, but I just read on a Beck blog this:

"Last November, Beck and his band covered on stage, “Star Power.” This is a Sonic Youth song from their album EVOL. A few months later, it was announced that Beck was releasing a cover of “Green Light,” which is also from EVOL. That release was a single, the b-side being a Sonic Youth cover of “Pay No Mind” no less! What does all this EVOLness mean? We learned today, thanks to our friends in Japan, that Beck has covered the whole album. He said this in an interview/article with a Japanese magazine. I’m told it will be part of some Sonic Youth box set. I know SY has been releasing Deluxe versions of their albums, so maybe EVOL Deluxe? Or maybe some greater box set project?
Regardless, this is super interesting and really a fun thing for Beck to have done!"

I personally really loved Beck's cover of Green Light so hopefully one day we might be able to here this. Since Moshe hasn't said anything about this or about an EVOL deluxe I'm not getting my hopes too up though. None the less I think both would be amazing.



Whoa. I'm not a huge Beck fan, only like his stuff every once in a while, but the Green Light cover was cool enough that I'd really like to hear that.

Kannibal 05.09.2009 06:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by toxic johnny
I am enjoying the Pay No Mind cover very much... it is pure deconstruction bliss.


this song made me listen SY again.

nicfit 05.09.2009 07:32 AM

It's kinda sad to see all those copies on ebay.

greedrex 05.09.2009 07:33 AM

^^ yeah notices that yesterday also. The discs aren't amazing though...especially Yoof-wise.

Jim72 07.23.2014 10:12 AM

Hearing this for the first time right now, odd fit... kinda works though. Drums are particularly awesome.

Jim72 07.23.2014 10:13 AM

Beck's cover is neat

RanaldoNecro 07.24.2014 10:26 AM

Everyone should check out "Won't be Long" by Beck. It features a sick bass line.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:01 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth