Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   good band, bad singer (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=24478)

Torn Curtain 08.17.2008 07:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
Exactly, Death and the Maiden.

I should have called it "good bad, shitty VOCALIST".


Ok, so only Ringo fits :D

batreleaser 08.17.2008 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
Deerhoof's vocals are beautiful.

Batreleaser, I'm not a huge fan of Glassjaw or Blood Brothers, but musically they are both actually pretty interesting bands. I have to admit it even though it's embarassing. The vocals just ruin any chance of them ever being taken seriously though.

SlipKnot actually have a lot of interesting musical ideas too, especially on their self-titled album but the "RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH" Cory Taylor growl pretty much always ruins it for me.


i like slipknot's first album. its totally unpretentious straight up metal. and loud. and heavy. and the last song borders on tribal psychedelic noise, all those yelps and screams and percussion.

Trasher02 08.17.2008 09:50 AM

Die! Die! Die! has a very irritating singer.

batreleaser 08.17.2008 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Torn Curtain
Neil Young. He kinda has a duck voice but that doesn't prevent it from being moving on his best songs.


surely you must be kidding. ian curtis and neil young!!! ian has one of the most sound appropriate voices of all time, somber, low, atmospheric, and totally beautiful! and neil young, that whiny falsetto that is capable of leading the saddest ballads as well as the most fist pumping excellent hard rock songs! two of the best male vocalists of all time.

i got one; yoko ono. the music is usually pretty interesting, but i HATE her voice. i know some find it creative of different or appropriate to the music, but i just find it deliberate, annoying, and cringe inducing.

SuperCreep 08.17.2008 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by batreleaser
i got one; yoko ono. the music is usually pretty interesting, but i HATE her voice. i know some find it creative of different or appropriate to the music, but i just find it deliberate, annoying, and cringe inducing.

Agreed. I actually found her debut to be surprisingly quite good, but I doubt I'll listen to it any more since I just can't stand her voice.

chairman of the bored 08.17.2008 11:08 AM

did anyone else see gang gang dance at summerstage yesterday?...there you go...

Savage Clone 08.17.2008 12:59 PM

I love Kyuss musically, but the vocals have always been a problem for me.

Torn Curtain 08.17.2008 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by batreleaser
surely you must be kidding. ian curtis and neil young!!! ian has one of the most sound appropriate voices of all time, somber, low, atmospheric, and totally beautiful! and neil young, that whiny falsetto that is capable of leading the saddest ballads as well as the most fist pumping excellent hard rock songs! two of the best male vocalists of all time.


I love their voices but that doesn't prevent me from noticing their strong technical limitations. I mean good voice doesn't equal good singing. But off course then technique is not what matters most in order to appreciate music.

Torn Curtain 08.17.2008 01:47 PM

And as was already said I misundertood what the thread was about so my references to Curtis and Young were off topic anyway.

atsonicpark 08.17.2008 05:42 PM

I was kinda thinking Kyuss too.

Usually the vocals are fine but sometimes they can be distracting...

SuperCreep 08.17.2008 06:42 PM

I find Kyuss' vocals to be bland and extremely off-putting.

Derek 08.17.2008 06:44 PM

I don't mind 'em.

demonrail666 08.17.2008 06:58 PM

I don't mind them either. I think Kyuss are one of those few bands where that kind of vocals really works.

atari 2600 08.17.2008 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xxlouiisxx
Smashing Pumpkins are very good, Billy Corgan sucks.


He actually sounded very good when I saw them. And the new band members did too. It was a pleasant surprise.

In my view, the "good band, bad singer" phenom pervades most music today. Most are incredibly bad lyricists to boot.

MellySingsDoom 08.17.2008 07:32 PM

atari2600 - I hate the studio/live "autotune" thing for vocalists - if you can't sing in the first place, any amount of technology isn't going to save your hide.

atsonicpark 08.17.2008 07:52 PM

The Sick Lipstick.

Awesome music; kinda no wave meets new wave or something... actually, it reminds me of the sound Wire had on "Send".. that really overprocessed sound... but with a no wave kind of sound...

But with the brattiest, cattiest, riot grrlish, loudest, most annoying vocals ever that dominate every song and automatically makes the whole band seem shitty.

atari 2600 08.17.2008 07:54 PM

An aside, but a guy at dime trades with the tour manager for Smashing Pumpkins and Billy ended up requesting some Booker T & the MGs. Some was used for the pre-show music.

fugazifan 08.18.2008 03:25 AM

this is probably an unpopular opinion but when i heard the new Suishou No Fune i couldnt get past how amazing the music would be without their singer...

atsonicpark 08.18.2008 07:47 AM

:(:(:(

Savage Clone 08.18.2008 07:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fugazifan
this is probably an unpopular opinion but when i heard the new Suishou No Fune i couldnt get past how amazing the music would be without their singer...


I think Pirako is great!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth