They suck.

I like the main riff in "zero" though.

I bet egg girl's farts smell so rotten...I'd like her to fart right in my face bare ass then I'd lick her asshole

Egg Girl

I'd vote for Mayonaise or one of the other tracks no one really notices on Siamese Dream. (Disarm and Cherub Rock are shit)

I wish MACHINA and MACHINA II could have been released together as a double album. I do not understand all the dislike for MACHINA and I need not to because it doesn't matter... I like it. "With Every Light" will always be one of my favorite songs.

I just listened to a random selection of their stuff on youtube. I've always maintained that I hated them without actually having listened to them. Now that I have though, I properly hate them.

EDIT: Hate's too strong a word. One song I heard I liked, but I don't remember which one it was.

need an inbetween option in the poll...

i like everything up to mcolie

Stopped listening to them ages ago. I used to be obsessed by them but now I find them just plain annoying. Billy is a major twat.

At least they consistently get hot bass players.

Weren't they recorded separately? MACHINA with D in the band, and II with her replacement.

along with my rankings, since no one asked:


Siamese Dream
Adore
Melloncollie
Pisces
Gish
Machina II
Machina
Zeitgeist

I just realized I lost my copy of Judas O!!! dammit!

They're far better than most radio rock, and I've always loved some songs and hated others...



^ But there is just no excuse for this hunk of shit.

meh. I'd give Zeit a 5/10. I dnt find it as bad as most ppl do I guess.

Zeitgeist = 3, for me. Gish is my favourite, Machina is my least favourite

Machina is also my least fav.

Machina 2 was alright though.

yes it was. "Dross" should've been a single

Yes.

Machina II is soooo much better than Machina I, with the exception of "The Imploding Voice".

The Machina II versions of TRY!, and heavy metal machine are better, even though both heavy metal machines arent that great.

Slow Dawn off Machina II is a classic SP song

Very true. I put the Machina II version of Try on a mix cd I made for my wife when we first started dating. :D

Try is a great song video...When Billy get sit right, its great. Lina Moy is an favourite

I listen to Machina II a lot. It's a great album.

I think there's great stuff on siamese dream, at least. but this is one of those bands I should've gotten into about 12 years ago, if I ever were to get into them, and I didn't nor I ever really heard their albums. Anyway, corgan's been doing great job at becoming a boring old hack.

blah blah blah

I'm pretty sure it was intended to be released as a double album, but Virgin would not allow it.

I thought it was that Machina II was sposed to be a double album, and Virgin didn't like it so Billy & Co. released it themselves? Maybe I'm wrong. But the 2 albums DO sound like diff. sessions to my ears.

Virgin didn't want MACHINA to be a double album because the Adore sales weren't so impressive. They also refused to release II separately, so Billy released it himself... just five months after the first.

The whole MACHINA saga is a bit confusing.

At least one thing is for sure, ADORE is the greatest album of all time.

(Maybe not, but it's amazing)

one of the 15 MACHINA II vinyl records Billy gave to fans was put up for sale on Ebay. price went as high as $3,000 i think, but he changed his mind

Jesus, help me find my proper place

yes, I love ADORE.

I find Billy exhausting. But he does write great stuff. I saw them a couple monthes ago and the MC/SD/Gish band is dead.

The violinsit was super-hot...

Yes, she is.

did everyone already hear that the drummer left?? so billy is the only original member now.

yes. Jimmy Chamberland left. Like 2 wks ago.

I relistened to some of my Smashing Pumpkins records yesterday... which I had not done for a few years. Siamese Dream has some of the most PERFECT songs ever... honestly, Soma, Mayonaise and Luna are all amazing. Pieces Iscariot or whatever it's called has some great songs on it... some horrible...

and Adore... well, I like one or two songs. :o

I'm waiting any day now for some indie shit band to do a loud electric version of "Disarm" and have a hit single.