Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   petition: who wants SYR7 on CD !? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=20221)

mil_pl 03.06.2008 03:44 PM

fuck vinyl is for chosen ones :P
everyone got cd players, and it should came out on both..
i want syrs (1-7) in box!

Rob Instigator 03.06.2008 03:50 PM

I want Kim's hot box!

Everyneurotic 03.06.2008 07:44 PM

i want it for free.

who starts the "give syr7 to everyneurotic for free" thread?

✌➬ 03.06.2008 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Everyneurotic
i want it for free.

who starts the "give syr7 to everyneurotic for free" thread?


For those who want to contribute, can go here.

Protectmeyou 03.08.2008 04:35 AM

screw crappy cd's, put it out on vinyl only.

SYRFox 03.08.2008 06:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Protectmeyou
screw crappy cd's, put it out on vinyl only.

You know what? Shut the fuck up. This thread is for people that want SYR7 on CD, we already have had a lot of talking about CD vs Vinyl lately so there's no need to come back again and repeat again this statement. I do not get angry easily but this vinyl thing really begins to get on my nerve. Does anybody came to say "Screw those old vinyls, put SYR 6 on CD only"? No, so please let us hope for a CD release that won't get out anyway, and go back to your turntable.

iskandertime 03.08.2008 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mil_pl
fuck vinyl is for chosen ones :P
everyone got cd players, and it should came out on both..
i want syrs (1-7) in box!


I don't want it to come out on CD. every one has a turntable, why waste time puting it out on CD?

iskandertime 03.08.2008 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
You know what? Shut the fuck up. This thread is for people that want SYR7 on CD, we already have had a lot of talking about CD vs Vinyl lately so there's no need to come back again and repeat again this statement. I do not get angry easily but this vinyl thing really begins to get on my nerve. Does anybody came to say "Screw those old vinyls, put SYR 6 on CD only"? No, so please let us hope for a CD release that won't get out anyway, and go back to your turntable.


Why does this get on your nerves? Just get a turntable, they are cheap to buy and easy to use. Or don't, but why get so excited about it? If you don't want records then don't by them. Just ignore the 100 years worth of music crated before CDs were invented and pretend they dident happen. It's not a big deal, no one has time to listen to everything; Just dont worry about vinyl only releases, or buy a turntable. No big deal. Everyone is happy. Peace reigns.

syouth69 03.08.2008 06:45 PM

SYR7 in CD format NOW!!!!!

Everyneurotic 03.08.2008 06:57 PM

chill out, it has been released in any format yet.

noisereductions 03.08.2008 07:18 PM

Alright, people who want SYR7 on vinyl go over there. People who want it on CD over here. We're gonna have ourselves a fucking tug-o-war.

Everyneurotic 03.08.2008 08:02 PM

i want it on sheet music, where do i stand?

✌➬ 03.09.2008 02:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Everyneurotic
i want it on sheet music, where do i stand?


HAHA...HAHAHA.....HAHAHA...HA...HA...

SYRFox 03.09.2008 03:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iskandertime
Why does this get on your nerves? Just get a turntable, they are cheap to buy and easy to use. Or don't, but why get so excited about it? If you don't want records then don't by them. Just ignore the 100 years worth of music crated before CDs were invented and pretend they dident happen. It's not a big deal, no one has time to listen to everything; Just dont worry about vinyl only releases, or buy a turntable. No big deal. Everyone is happy. Peace reigns.

The thing that gets on my nerve is people coming just to say that CDs are shit. I'm sorry, maybe vinyls are better, but CDs still are quality stuff. And I don't want to buy a turntable just for SYR 7. For the moment, that's the only record I want that's only going to be released on vinyl, so I won't buy a turntable just for it. But I would still want to listen to it, so I'd be glad if it came out in CD, which is actually the topic of this thread.

Protectmeyou 03.09.2008 03:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
You know what? Shut the fuck up. This thread is for people that want SYR7 on CD, we already have had a lot of talking about CD vs Vinyl lately so there's no need to come back again and repeat again this statement. I do not get angry easily but this vinyl thing really begins to get on my nerve. Does anybody came to say "Screw those old vinyls, put SYR 6 on CD only"? No, so please let us hope for a CD release that won't get out anyway, and go back to your turntable.



It's called an opinion man and everyone's entitled to voicing it without getting abused. You're a child who needs to learn to grown up.

This vinyl thing gets on your nerves does it? Well self righteous teenage wankers get on mine.

SYRFox 03.09.2008 04:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Protectmeyou
It's called an opinion man and everyone's entitled to voicing it without getting abused. You're a child who needs to learn to grown up.

This vinyl thing gets on your nerves does it? Well self righteous teenage wankers get on mine.

You don't get what I meant, maybe I was too rude. What I meant is that I don't see the need to criticize CDs once again on a thread that was, at first, for people asking for a CD version of SYR7. Your message came like provocation on there. Especially because we already had this kinda opinions / arguments on it.

L3BURST 03.09.2008 06:45 AM

Sorry, but I'll do a bit of provocation, just to continue the debate...This is my point of view...I know it's extreme and I respect others but:

I just want music !!

Good files are perfect for me !! (the quality differences between MP3 192 - 320 - FLAC - WAVE is another debate)...and I'll wait for this version of SYR7 !! (for free or for a few € is also another debate)

Vinyls, casettes and CD's are for nostalgic materialists !! Do you sometimes think they are made of transformed oil and trees and generate much more pollution for their production and transport ??

Not so romantic !? Why do you write here and not with a letter written with ink and a feather ? Or with smoke signals ? ...

Artwork !? Why should we be forced to listen to Renaissance music when we just want to enjoy watching Monalisa ? ...I like to watch Kim's paintings, but not allways at the same time as I listen to her music !

I love the "immateriality" of music !

does somebody want this SYR7 version ??

 

PAULYBEE2656 03.09.2008 08:38 AM

vinyl is shit, cds are shit, mp3 are for loosers, flac is bright pink, fuck you all format junkies!! this is bollocks.,.... i want syr7 on cd because i have the others on cd. they all look cool as one package. my biggest disappointment so far in the series is the photo on the syr6 cover, it didnt fit in with the other releases. now the 7th installment is on vinyl only???? taklk about fucking with a collection of gems. why bother doing this if it is only gonna screw up someones collection. i am a bit peeved over this but i will end up buying it on vinyl anyway because i have the ability to play vinyl.

format junkies are stupid. its 2008, cdphobia and vinylecclectisim is sooooo 1999 yknow! if sy had any sense they would release it on cd anyway after a period of time, in fact id like to wager a bet that that will happen anyway!

█████████ 03.09.2008 10:27 AM

uh... i'll give my opinion once again,

this is not up to us to choose... it's up to the band, it's up to them to choose to fit a musical piece in a determined context and all that it implies, artwork, technical aspects etc...

this time if they choose vinyl, instead of complaining about it, deal with it, try to understand why they did so.

would you complain to a painter for painting on canvas instead of paper?

iskandertime 03.09.2008 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
The thing that gets on my nerve is people coming just to say that CDs are shit. I'm sorry, maybe vinyls are better, but CDs still are quality stuff. And I don't want to buy a turntable just for SYR 7. For the moment, that's the only record I want that's only going to be released on vinyl, so I won't buy a turntable just for it. But I would still want to listen to it, so I'd be glad if it came out in CD, which is actually the topic of this thread.


Fair enough, you just seemed so mad!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth