Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Do you like Led Zeppelin? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=35420)

FreshChops 10.23.2009 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Another one of those bands I've tried and tried until I cried and cried. I think, short of taking a bath in man-paste, I really can't think of a more homo-erotic experience than listening to Cock Zeppelin.


I agree they've got some all out obnoxious cock-rock anthems, and that tends to be their most popular, but some of their mellow stuff is just straight great songwriting. If legitimately you're turned off by the testosterone driven stuff, check out these fem-tastic ones .... seriously :)

• Going to California
• Tangerine
• That's the way
• The Rain Song


As far I can recall too, they might have been the first band to really coin the signature song-writing style where they start mellow and pretty and then unload to a heavy part. How many rock bands do this today, all of them? samples of theirs are:

Stairway to Heaven
Over The Hills and Far Away
Ramble On, among others......

are we becoming such music snobs that we ignorantly shun the pioneers of music of their generations? What's next, Beatles overrated? Nirvana sucks?

SONIC GAIL 10.23.2009 12:04 PM

agreed.the radio is tryin to kellem.

automatic bzooty 10.23.2009 12:15 PM

tangerine is such a gorgeous song.

!@#$%! 10.23.2009 01:55 PM

of course i love them, they are awesome-- what's not to like? their "classic rock" fans? sure-- but don't be a twatty scenester & listen to good music by yourself. great fucking blues-based rock, best of the 70s, savage drums, great guitar, great bass, plant was a bit much at times but i can't quit you babe is such a fucking great song and haters can shrivel up like dead cocks.

Glice 10.23.2009 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FreshChops
I

are we becoming such music snobs that we ignorantly shun the pioneers of music of their generations? What's next, Beatles overrated? Nirvana sucks?


Thanks for the tips - I will go back to them, but I do own the first four albums and every now and then try again to get them, and fail.

I think the thing with pioneers is that there's fucking loads of them. Personally, I don't like Zep and I can't stand the Beatles, but you pick the pioneers that suit you. I don't expect everyone to agree that, say, Hank Williams is one of the most seminal artists of the 20th Century, but he's a pioneer that I like. Very few people on this message board listen to Tallis, Downland, JS Bach and the like (and I'd go further and say that many have no idea who Dowland or Tallis are) but their musical pioneer status is irrefutable. Unless anyone wants to refute it, in which case, cool, have fun, help yourself to a prize from the prize trolley.

acousticrock87 10.23.2009 03:23 PM

I do like them when they're on, but not enough to listen to on purpose.

And I wouldn't care much to bother seeing one of their reunions.

Seandi 10.23.2009 03:55 PM

Not as much as Uriah Heep.

Hip Priest 10.23.2009 05:06 PM

Not really. A lot of their music is OK, some of it I really enjoy, but I could do without the vocals. I'm not often keen on vocals, and especially high-pitched rocky type vocals.

Hip Priest 10.23.2009 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seandi
Not as much as Uriah Heep.


Was he a big Zep fan?

chairman of the bored 10.23.2009 05:25 PM

baby baby baby baby baby baby baby baby baby
baby baby baby
baby baby baby baby baby baby baby baby

pbradley 10.23.2009 05:29 PM

The Beatles are overrated.

Nirvana sucks.

Conrad 10.23.2009 06:54 PM

I used to, during my classic rock faze.

Now I can't stand them, although they're better than ACDC and all that other crap.

Trasher02 10.23.2009 06:57 PM

Never cared much for them. They never managed to make me interested so, nope.

dionysusundone 10.23.2009 08:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conrad
Now I can't stand them, although they're better than ACDC and all that other crap.


I'll grant that. I fucking HATE AC/DC.

Genteel Death 11.08.2009 11:04 AM

Jimmy Page's soundtrack for Lucifer Rising is pretty amazing.

MellySingsDoom 11.08.2009 11:36 AM

Senor Genteel - Jimmy Page didn't end up doing the souundtrack to Lucifer Rising, due to falling out with Anger. It was actually composed and performed by Manson Family geezer Bobby Beausoleil - and very good it is too.

Skuj 11.08.2009 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FreshChops
I agree they've got some all out obnoxious cock-rock anthems, and that tends to be their most popular, but some of their mellow stuff is just straight great songwriting. If legitimately you're turned off by the testosterone driven stuff, check out these fem-tastic ones .... seriously :)

• Going to California
• Tangerine
• That's the way
• The Rain Song


As far I can recall too, they might have been the first band to really coin the signature song-writing style where they start mellow and pretty and then unload to a heavy part. How many rock bands do this today, all of them? samples of theirs are:

Stairway to Heaven
Over The Hills and Far Away
Ramble On, among others......

are we becoming such music snobs that we ignorantly shun the pioneers of music of their generations? What's next, Beatles overrated? Nirvana sucks?


Good post. (Although, some will say that about Beatles and Nirvana.)

I voted no, but I do accept that Zep has done some great stuff. I love Kashmir (precisely because it is so ott hahaha?) and a lot of the Houses Of The Holy lp. But there's a lot of wankery / posing in this band. They must have inspired Spinal Tap? I think that 1976 lp, (forget the name, Achilles Last Stand is on it) is fucking awful. A lot of the early stuff is so heavy handed, Led Zepellin indeed. At least the last lp was ballsy....in that they tried a new sound. The middle solo thing of All Of My Love is actually quite fucking great, and I've always been able to whistle it, note perfect, hahaha...

Genteel Death 11.08.2009 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MellySingsDoom
Senor Genteel - Jimmy Page didn't end up doing the souundtrack to Lucifer Rising, due to falling out with Anger. It was actually composed and performed by Manson Family geezer Bobby Beausoleil - and very good it is too.

i know that, i am talking about the unreleased version by jimmy page. I agree that they're both great.

Keeping It Simple 11.08.2009 01:25 PM

I hate the band.

Genteel Death 11.08.2009 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Keeping It Simple
I hate the band.

this thread is about led zep

reginald 11.08.2009 07:09 PM

I like up through HOTH, their fifth album.

I don't like the prancing that Robert Plant did in his feminine frilly laced blouses as he became the Golden God! Oh Brother!!!

I kinda think he's embarrassed by that posture he projected now that he's in his golden years....He's much more humble and restrained now. Jimmy Page is basically retired and hasn't put any new music out in a decade, JPJ has joined with Dave Grohl and Josh Holmes and they have a new band, The Crooked Vultures. JPJ has had the most significant post-Zep music originality of the 3 surviving ex-Zepsters IMO.

The "re-union" with John Bonham's son, Jason, actually has some great material on it. He did his father proud. Plant's voice was better than it's been for Zep material since 1972 !!!

ricechex 11.08.2009 07:14 PM

How can you not like Led Zeppelin? I imagine there are some that think they're too cool for the Zep.

Satan 11.08.2009 07:36 PM

i was just listening to them. nothing beats when jimmy whips out the violin bow. gimmick or not.

 

Satan 11.08.2009 07:44 PM

i could listen to page jack the guitar allll day. fuck the haters.

Dead-Air 11.08.2009 07:51 PM

I just put on "I" right now. When "Your Time is Gonna Come" comes on, I'm going to turn it up to 11. Lennon started playing his toy piano along to "Good Times, Bad Times" and totally nailed it too.

ricechex 11.08.2009 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
there are plenty of those sorts.

the same sorta people that use phrases like "guitar masterbation" to describe anything that a) doesnt have thurston moore's seal of approval, or b) is harder to play than the ramones.


Sure, and what's weird is I don't see Zep as a jam band/guitar masturbating band. Live they tried to jam more, but honestly weren't that good, mainly bc Jimmy was too wasted and/or improvising wasn't his forte. It was in the studio and arranging his parts that was brilliant to me...closer to the Gilmour/Floyd approach bc every note of his recorded parts were huge for the song.

EVOLghost 11.08.2009 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricechex
How can you not like Led Zeppelin? I imagine there are some that think they're too cool for the Zep.

No one is too cool for led zep

EVOLghost 11.08.2009 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricechex
Sure, and what's weird is I don't see Zep as a jam band/guitar masturbating band. Live they tried to jam more, but honestly weren't that good, mainly bc Jimmy was too wasted and/or improvising wasn't his forte. It was in the studio and arranging his parts that was brilliant to me...closer to the Gilmour/Floyd approach bc every note of his recorded parts were huge for the song.

Still good live though. I can listen to Jimmy groove on how the west won all day

ricechex 11.08.2009 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EVOLghost
Still good live though. I can listen to Jimmy groove on how the west won all day


Oh yeah, the live double dvd thing that was released a few years back is excellent.

Satan 11.08.2009 11:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Satan
i was just listening to them. nothing beats when jimmy whips out the violin bow. gimmick or not.

 

this also reminds me

how many more times is better than dazed and confused.


and


the sex pistols are irrelevant.

Satan 11.08.2009 11:34 PM

they're very relevant to fashion. important to music as well, it's undeniable. but as far as nastiness goes they were certainly a manufactured nastiness at least to some extent.

Satan 11.08.2009 11:49 PM

this is true. people don't think about that for some reason.

the fashion part of it is great anyway. contrived or not. long live vivienne westwood.

Dead-Air 11.08.2009 11:55 PM

Lydon was a great writer who brought lyrics to rock 'n roll that weren't there before. Cool voice too. The band itself a bit overrated, but the impact can't be denied.

Today I'd rather listen to "Anarchy in the UK" than "Kashmir", but that's mostly due to personal circumstances (I was in a car that rolled over in high school while listening to "Kashmir" on my walkman).

It doesn't surprise me that Page liked the Pistols as he could tell a good rock band when he saw one.

Satan 11.08.2009 11:58 PM

 

Count Mecha 11.09.2009 12:04 AM

Zep's cool. I fucking adore Your Time Is Gonna Come and Babe I'm Gonna Leave You. Probably one of the best band compositions we'll ever see. Every guy in that band pulls their weight.

Satan 11.09.2009 12:06 AM

my fav is satellite

i have no idea who actually wrote that? was it them? some demo shit.

Skuj 11.09.2009 12:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
there are plenty of those sorts.

the same sorta people that use phrases like "guitar masterbation" to describe anything that a) doesnt have thurston moore's seal of approval, or b) is harder to play than the ramones.


Hahahaha.....

Jesus Christ people, some of us don't like Zep, OK? If I ever hear Stairway again, "the greatest song ever", I'm going to throw up. I'd rather chew tinfoil than hear the first LP.....blues that go up to fucking 11. Subtlety was not a strong point here.

And no, I don't think I'm "too cool".

Satan 11.09.2009 12:22 AM

some situations don't call for subtlety. like rock and roll.
+
you can't help what you like.

Death & the Maiden 11.09.2009 12:40 AM

Houses of the Holy hasn't left my stereo for a few weeks now. I can now play The Rain Song on guitar.

Skuj 11.09.2009 01:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Satan
some situations don't call for subtlety. like rock and roll.
+
you can't help what you like.


Sure, and, you cannot help what you don't like.

I'm not sure where I'm going here, but folks, what lasting influence has Zep had on other musicians / music?

I wish I could find what Pete Townshend said about Zep, hahaha....I found myself completely agreeing with him.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth