Their first album I thought was decent at best, second one ranged from being unmemorable (the majority of the album) to god awful (My Body Is A Cage)...I find it amazing that the awful song is the only one I can ever remember even a bit of how it goes, considering I worked in a store that played it non stop when it came out. Only heard one song from the new one and don't remember anything about it either.
So yeah, I guess I'll say suck.

I'd say they're ridiculously boring.

Just listened to the new album.

In two words: TOO LONG.

Seriously, it could have been great if they cut like 5 or 6 songs out. "Empty Room" and "Month of May" are awesome though.

I like em enough. In fact, I listened to Funeral quite a bit when it came out. Neon Bible was okay, and I haven't heard the new one at all as of yet.

I don't care much for them overall, but at the same time the fan-made video of my body is a cage with clips from once upon a time in the west is one of my favorite song/vids of all time.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pyp34v6Lmcc